asl search
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Anti-Snoring Reviews
Bedding Information
Bedding Reviews
Best Bed Frames
Best Comforters
Best Mattress
Best Mattress Pads
Best Mattress Protectors
Best Mattress Toppers
Best Pillowcases
Best Pillows
Best Sheets
Mattress Accessories
Mattress Comparisons
Mattress Coupons
Mattress Information
Mattress Reviews
Mattress Sales
Mattress Sizes
Mattress Topper Reviews
Pillow Reviews
Sheet Reviews
Sleep Environment
Sleep Products
Sleep Tracker Reviews
Weighted Blanket Reviews
Our editors test & choose the products we write about. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The Most Comfortable Mattresses Online – 2022 Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

Written by Tuck Staff

Quick Overview

Using a comfortable mattress can have a very positive effect on overall sleep quality and duration. Each bed is constructed for a certain firmness, or feel, and different mattress materials provide distinct levels of body-conforming and support. We encourage each mattress buyer to determine their ideal firmness and test out different mattress models in order to find the most comfortable bed.

Many of the most comfortable mattresses sold today are available through online-based companies. These brands face minimal overhead costs compared to their brick-and-mortar counterparts, allowing them to offer beds at relatively low prices. Most online mattress brands also offer free shipping and returns within the contiguous U.S., along with lengthy sleep trials for customers to test out their mattress.

This guide will discuss the most comfortable mattresses sold online. We’ll begin with our top eight mattress picks. These selections are based on reviews and experiences from verified mattress owners, as well as our own product testing and analysis. Below the top picks, you’ll find a comprehensive buyer’s guide that discusses why a comfortable mattress is important, how to choose the right model based on body type and personal preferences, and where to find the most comfortable mattress online.

Most Comfortable Mattresses Online
First Time Buying a Mattress Online?

Hop down to our Buyer’s Guide for a crash course on finding the most comfortable mattress online.


Best OverallSaatva

Best Overall – Saatva


  • Multiple firmness options (4, 6, 7.5)
  • 180-night sleep trial
  • 15-year warranty
  • Innovative coil-on-coil design
  • Consistent breathability and temperature neutrality
Read Our Full Review
Save $200 on the Saatva Mattress.
Learn More

Best OverallSaatva

Shop Now

Innersprings excel at responsiveness and overall support, but many models feel too firm for side sleepers and/or lighter people. The Saatva is a notable exception, and that is largely due to its firmness selection. Customers may choose from three firmness levels – medium firm (4), medium firm (6), or firm (7.5) – as well as 11.5-inch or 14.5-inch profiles. This range ensures most sleepers can find a comfortable option regardless of their body type, normal sleep position, or mattress preferences.

The Saatva is constructed with a padded Euro-top cover and comfort layers of polyfoam and memory foam. The transitional layer consists of pocketed minicoils, while the support core features recycled-steel bonnell coils. This coil-on-coil construction creates a very responsive surface and a feeling of sleeping “on” – as opposed to “in” – the mattress. Both coil layers circulate air very well to help the mattress maintain a comfortable temperature, making the Saatva a great option for hot sleepers.

Saatva offers free White Glove delivery anywhere in the contiguous U.S. This service includes in-home assembly and old mattress removal. The Saatva is also backed by a 180-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The low-cost Saatva redefines innerspring mattresses with a supportive coil-on-coil design and a wide range of firmness options.

  • Sleepers who prefer very responsive mattresses. Thanks to its coil-on-coil construction, the Saatva feels very responsive even when compared to other innerspring models.
  • People who like sleeping on thicker beds. The Saatva is available in 11.5-inch and 14.5-inch thicknesses, both of which are considered medium to high-profile beds.
  • Hot sleepers. Both coil layers promote steady airflow to help the mattress maintain a cool, comfortable temperature.
  • Buyers who do not want to set up the mattress themselves. Saatva offers free White Glove delivery for all customers, and this service includes full assembly in a room of the customer’s choice.

Not Recommended for...

  • Couples. Like other innersprings, the Saatva does not minimize motion transfer very well and the coils can be somewhat noisy. These characteristics could lead to sleep disruptions for those who share a bed.
  • Sleepers who prefer close body-conforming. The Saatva conforms somewhat to the sleeper – especially the medium soft model – but the mattress does not provide the pressure-relieving body cradle of an all-foam bed.

Best FoamT&N Mint Mattress

Best Foam – T&N Mint Mattress


  • Medium firm (6)
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Top layer infused with graphite and cooling gel
  • Excellent cushioning for shoulders and hips
Read Our Full Review
Get the best price on a T&N Mint Mattress.
Claim Discount

Best FoamT&N Mint Mattress

Shop Now

For many sleepers, all-polyfoam mattresses are a more comfortable alternative to memory foam beds. Polyfoam conforms to the body to alleviate pressure and align the spine, much like memory foam, but the material is also fairly responsive and sleepers do not sink too much. Our top pick among foam mattresses online is the T&N Mint Mattress, a medium firm model constructed with three individual layers that conform and alleviate pressure without hugging sleepers too closely.

The topmost layer consists of lower-density foam infused with graphite and cooling gel, giving the bed good surface breathability, while denser support layers reinforce the mattress to prevent excessive sagging. As is the case with other all-foam beds, the T&N Mint Mattress is a great choice for couples because it isolates motion very well and does not make any noise. The mattress has above-average durability, as well, due to its high-quality materials and construction.

An antimicrobial protectant embedded in the cover is designed to stave off harmful bacteria. Owners can also zip off the top half of the cover and launder it in their household machines. The T&N Mint Mattress is very affordable, even compared to other all-foam models (which are generally low-priced). Tuft & Needle also ships the mattress for free within the contiguous U.S.

The Bottom Line.

A high-value bed at a very reasonable price, the T&N Mint Mattress offers a balanced, mid-level firmness and exceptional pressure relief.

  • People who weigh 230 pounds or less. Due to its medium firm feel, the mattress is best suited to sleepers in the lightweight and average weight groups.
  • Sleepers who prefer a mix of conforming and responsiveness. The T&N Mint Mattress conforms to the sleeper’s body while maintaining strong overall support, and this results in a combined feeling of sleeping “on” and sleeping “in” the mattress.
  • Couples. We recommend the T&N Mint Mattress for co-sleepers due to its excellent motion isolation and no noise when bearing weight.
  • Value seekers. Considering its premium construction and strong performance, the mattress has a very low price-point.

Not Recommended for...

  • People who weigh more than 230 pounds. The T&N Mint Mattress may feel too soft and prone to sagging for those in the heavyweight group.
  • Sleepers who prefer deep body-conforming. The mattress conforms to noticeable extent, but it does not provide the same deep, pressure-relieving body cradle as models with memory foam comfort layers.

Best HybridBrooklyn Bedding Signature

Best Hybrid – Brooklyn Bedding Signature


  • Multiple firmness options (3.5, 5.5, 7.5)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Premium, pressure-relieving foam layers
  • Very good responsiveness and strong edge support
Read Our Full Review
Save 20% on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature with this checkout code = TUCKSLEEP20
Claim Discount

Best HybridBrooklyn Bedding Signature

Shop Now

Many sleepers consider hybrid mattresses to be the best of both worlds. Many hybrid models have thick comfort layers of foam and/or latex that conform to the body and alleviate pressure, along with thick pocketed coils to provide strong overall support. We’ve chosen the Brooklyn Bedding Signature for our top hybrid pick. The mattress is available in soft (3.5), medium (5.5), and firm (7.5) designs to accommodate sleepers with different body types and position preferences.

The Signature is constructed with two layers of premium polyfoam, giving sleepers plenty of cushioning. Its support core consists of 6-inch pocketed coils reinforced with another inch of high-density base foam. These components provide excellent stability for the mattress, which prevents excessive sagging and minimizes sinkage along the edges. The Signature is ideal for hot sleepers, as well. The foam layers don’t absorb too much body heat, while the coils promote strong airflow to keep the mattress cool.

The Signature is one of Brooklyn Bedding’s lowest-priced mattresses, making it a great value for customers. The company also offers free shipping to all 50 states and a 120-night sleep trial.

The Bottom Line.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s high-quality hybrid construction ensures a comfortable balance of body-contouring and support, but its price-point is much lower than average.

  • Side and back sleepers. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature performs strongly for sleepers with different positions, but the most favorable ratings come from those who sleep on their sides and/or back.
  • People who prefer a more responsive feel. The Signature conforms a bit to the sleeper’s body, but it also feels very responsive and supportive. This creates a feeling of sleeping “on” – and not “in” – the mattress for most.
  • Hot sleepers. Like other hybrids, the Signature generates enough airflow through its coil layer to keep the entire mattress fairly cool.
  • Couples. The Signature provides better motion isolation than many competing hybrids, and the pocketed coils are also reasonably quiet.

Not Recommended for...

  • Heavier stomach sleepers. After testing the mattress, we found stomach sleepers weighing 130 pounds or more find the mattress prone to excessive sagging.
  • Those who prefer close body-conforming. The mattress conforms a bit to sleepers but it does not provide the pressure-relieving cradle for their bodies like all-foam models with memory foam layers.

Best LatexAvocado Green Mattress

Best Latex – Avocado Green Mattress


  • Multiple firmness options (6, 7)
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • 25-year warranty
  • Durable, sustainably sourced materials
  • Excellent temperature neutrality
Read Our Full Review
Save $150 on the Avocado Green mattress with this checkout code = TUCKAVO
Claim Discount

Best LatexAvocado Green Mattress

Shop Now

Like hybrids, latex mattresses are a good compromise for many sleepers. The latex layers provide some body-conforming but also feel fairly responsive, so sleepers experience some pressure relief without sinking deeply into the mattress. Our top pick for this category is the Avocado Green, a latex hybrid made with layers of organic wool and natural Dunlop latex. These materials are naturally breathable to keep the surface at a cool temperature, and the wool also has moisture-wicking properties. Thick pocketed coils support the bed and promote steady airflow for added breathability.

Natural latex is an exceptionally durable material, giving the mattress a longer-than-average expected lifespan of about seven and a half to eight years. Customers can choose from a firmer design with one latex comfort layer, or a medium firm model with two comfort layers. Avocado also offers a vegan option that replaces the organic wool with organic cotton batting.

The Avocado Green is somewhat pricey compared to the average mattress of any type, but low-priced for a latex hybrid. Avocado also offers free shipping to the contiguous U.S., and backs the mattress with a 365-night sleep trial and a 25-year warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The Avocado Green is a comfortable, eco-friendly mattress made with premium natural latex and thick, supportive pocketed coils.

  • People who weigh at least 130 pounds. The Avocado Green performs well for sleepers across different body types, but its most positive ratings come from those in the average weight and heavyweight groups.
  • Hot sleepers. The Avocado Green provides excellent temperature neutrality thanks to its moisture-wicking wool and breathable latex layers, as well as strong airflow through its coil system.
  • Sleepers who prefer more responsive mattresses. The Avocado Green is fairly bouncy due to its naturally responsive latex and springy coil system.
  • Eco-conscious shoppers. The mattress is made from natural latex, organic wool and cotton, and other sustainably sourced materials. A vegan-friendly, wool-free design is also available.

Not Recommended for...

  • People who weigh less than 130 pounds. The mattress will likely feel too firm and not conform closely enough for lightweight sleepers.
  • Sleepers who prefer close body-conforming. The Avocado Green’s latex layer(s) conform somewhat to the sleeper’s body, but not to the same extent as memory foam or polyfoam.

Best LuxuryLuxury Firm WinkBed

Best Luxury – Luxury Firm WinkBed


  • Medium firm (6.5) feel
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Strong coil-on-coil design
  • Zoned coils offer excellent edge support
Read Our Full Review
Get $300 off a WinkBed mattress. Use code: TUCK300
Claim Discount

Best LuxuryLuxury Firm WinkBed

Shop Now

We define a luxury mattress as any model featuring durable, high-quality materials and a sophisticated design that delivers exceptional comfort and support to most sleepers. It’s important to note that luxury mattresses do not necessarily have high price-points. For instance, the Luxury Firm WinkBed – our Best Luxury pick – has a price-point that is lower than that of the average hybrid, but thanks to its innovative design the mattress is both luxurious and affordable.

The Luxury Firm WinkBed is constructed with a Euro-top quilted with polyfoam, followed by a transitional layer of SupportCell polyfoam. The Euro-top provides excellent cushioning for pressure points, while the SupportCell layer balances out contouring with a moderate amount of pushback. Beneath is a support core of pocketed coils. Strong airflow through the coils ensures temperature neutrality for hot sleepers. The coils are also zoned with thicker springs reinforcing the edges while thinner springs cradle the sleeper, resulting in enhanced support.

The WinkBed is available in two additional firmness levels besides the Luxury Firm option, as well as the WinkBed Plus – which swaps in a latex layer for a firm (8) feel that is specifically designed to accommodate heavier people. The WinkBed’s wide selection should accommodate most customers regardless of their body type, sleep position, or comfort preferences.

WinkBeds provides free shipping anywhere in the contiguous U.S., along with a 120-night sleep trial. The bed comes with a lifetime warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The Luxury Firm WinkBed is constructed with a thick comfort system and zoned coils for enhanced support.

  • Sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds. The Luxury Firm WinkBed provides close body-conforming but also feels very supportive, making it best suited to sleepers in the lightweight and average weight groups.
  • People who prefer beds with zoned coils. The WinkBed protects the edges from sinkage with thicker coils along the perimeter, while thinner coils offer enhanced support to the sleeper’s body.
  • Hot sleepers. The WinkBed promotes steady airflow through its coils to keep the mattress at a cool and comfortable temperature.

Not Recommended for...

  • Sleepers who prefer deep body-conforming. The WinkBed features foam comfort layers that contour to the body, but the mattress does not provide the same pressure-relieving cradle as models with memory foam.
  • People who like sleeping on lower-profile mattresses. The WinkBed has an above-average profile, making it fairly tall even compared to other high-profile mattresses.

Comfortable Mattresses Online Buying Guide

This guide discusses how mattress buyers can find the most comfortable bed based on their body type, sleep position, firmness preferences, and other criteria. We’ll also look at tips for comparing different mattress models from online brands. Keep reading to learn more.

Buyer’s Guide for Comfortable Mattresses Online

Defining Mattress Comfort

We define comfortable mattresses as models that cushion the body, alleviate pressure, and provide adequate support without causing new aches and pains to occur. However, mattress comfort is entirely subjective. A bed that relieves pressure and feels supportive to one sleeper might feel uneven and excessively firm or soft to another. In order to determine which mattress will be most comfortable, shoppers should take the following factors into account.


When discussing mattresses, “firmness” refers to how soft or firm the surface feels.
Softer beds tend to conform more closely to the sleeper’s body and lack strong support systems, while firmer models may not contour as much but they keep sleepers on a more even plane.

Every sleeper’s ideal firmness level depends on certain individual factors, such as body type and sleep position. For example, softer beds may be ideal for lightweight side sleepers because they conform closely and cushion the shoulders and hips, which alleviates pressure and promotes even spinal alignment. Heavier stomach sleepers, on the other hand, may need a firmer bed to support their midsection and prevent them from sagging excessively.

At Tuck Sleep, we use the 1-10 scale to evaluate mattress firmness. Most mattresses sold today fall between a 3 (soft) and an 8.5 (firm). The table below illustrates mattress qualities based on different firmness levels.

Firmness (1-10) Description Conforming Level Ideal Sleeper Weight/Position
1 to 3 Extra-Soft to Soft The mattress conforms very closely. Soft mattresses are best suited to lightweight individuals – particularly side sleepers who experience better spinal alignment with more padding for their bodies. Heavier people will probably find these mattresses too soft and prone to excessive sagging.
4 to 4.5 Medium-Soft The mattress conforms closely, but sleepers don’t sink excessively. medium soft mattresses provide good conforming and cushioning for heavier side sleepers and back/stomach sleepers who weigh 130 to 230 pounds.
5 to 5.5 Medium The mattress offers a balanced feel, conforming a bit while also feeling fairly supportive. Many lightweight to average weight sleepers consider medium the ideal firmness because it combines body-conforming and support. Heavier sleepers who like some conforming may also feel comfortable.
6 to 6.5 Medium-Firm The mattress conforms to a moderate extent, but the bed mostly feels supportive. Most medium firm beds are best suited to side, back, and stomach sleepers who weigh at least 130 pounds. Lighter people will likely find them too firm.
7 to 10 Firm to Extra-Firm The mattress conforms to a very minimal extent, and most sleepers remain on a completely even plane with little to no sinking. Many heavier back and stomach sleepers feel very comfortable on firm to extra-firm mattresses. Most lighter people – especially side sleepers – do not receive enough body conforming or pressure relief.

It’s important to note that these firmness descriptions are completely subjective. Someone weighing less than 130 pounds may find a firm or extra-firm mattress most comfortable, while a heavyweight back or stomach sleeper may prefer softer beds. Testing out beds with different firmness levels is the best way to find the most comfortable mattress.


Mattress support refers to how well the bed keeps the sleeper’s body on an even plane. Support is somewhat tied to firmness. Softer mattresses often have thicker comfort layers and lack strong support systems. As a result, these beds provide optimal body-conforming and pressure relief for lighter individuals, but they tend to sag too much for heavyweight sleepers.

Firmer mattresses, on the other hand, usually have thicker and denser support layers to prevent sleepers from sinking deeply beneath the surface. These models provide extra reinforcement for larger sleepers, but lighter individuals may not experience adequate body-conforming or pressure relief.

In addition to firmness level, a bed’s material construction can also affect support. Models with coil systems tend to offer the best support. Most mattress coils are made from steel and fairly thick, which keeps the mattress stable and prevents sleepers from sagging. Latex layers also offer decent support because they withstand sagging well. Models with polyfoam support layers typically provide the weakest support, as this material can sag over time.


Responsiveness refers to how quickly the mattress reacts, or responds to the sleeper’s body. Mattresses with thick memory foam layers usually respond the slowest. The foam – which is temperature-reactive – gradually contours to the sleeper as it softens from their body heat. Polyfoam is a bit more responsive than memory foam but sleepers still experience a gradual body hug as the material adapts to their figure. All-foam beds are the best option for sleepers who like slowly responding mattresses.

The most responsive mattresses are usually hybrids and innersprings, both of which are equipped with coil systems that make the surface feel noticeably springy. Beds with latex can also feel responsive, as the material is naturally bouncy. People who prefer more responsiveness from their bed should consider one of these mattress types. Many couples prefer more responsive mattresses for sex, as well.

Temperature Neutrality

Many people naturally run hot, and this can cause them to sleep excessively warm at night. For this reason, some mattresses are designed to sleep cooler and more temperature-neutral. Materials and features that promote temperature neutrality include:

  • Cooling Covers: Fabrics known for breathability, such as cotton and Tencel lyocell, can help a mattress cover sleep cool. Some beds also feature covers with phase-change material, which is designed to retain body heat until the surface of the mattress reaches an optimal temperature.
  • Ventilated Comfort Layers: Comfort layer foam and/or latex may be ventilated with tiny holes to promote airflow to the bed’s surface.
  • Coil Systems: Hybrids and innersprings with coil layers promote strong airflow throughout the interior of the mattress, and this can help the entire bed maintain a comfortable temperature.

This list is not exhaustive. Other components that improve temperature neutrality may include comfort foams infused with cooling gel or copper, wool layers that wick away moisture from sleeper’s bodies, and beds with firmer feels that promote strong surface airflow compared to those that conform closely around the body.

Selecting a Comfortable Mattress Online

In order to find the most comfortable bed online, we encourage all shoppers to do the following:

  • Comparison Shop: With so many mattresses sold online, shoppers can quickly become overwhelmed with the wide range of options. For this reason, buyers should focus on the mattress qualities they find most comfortable. Those who prefer close body-conforming and pressure relief should primarily look at all-foam mattresses, while those who would rather sleep on a more responsive and supportive bed may want to consider hybrids and innersprings instead. Be sure to compare prices, as well, since costs vary sharply by brand.
  • Read Product Reviews: Customer reviews can be tricky for mattress models, as some brands do not list negative reviews on their website – or at least make them difficult to access. We recommend web forums and discussion boards, as well as the reviews found on third-party retailer sites like These ratings tend to be more objective and less biased toward certain brands.
  • Discuss Comfort Preferences with a Sleep Partner: Many co-sleepers have differing preferences when it comes to firmness, support, and other mattress factors. Determining the best firmness level for both parties is crucial. In some cases, a model with dual-firmness – different firmness levels on each side – might be the best option.
  • Visit a Mattress Store: We don’t recommend buying a mattress in a brick-and-mortar store because models tend to have higher price-points due to more overhead costs. However, visiting a store to lie down on different mattresses can be a very helpful experience for shoppers who don’t know their ideal mattress firmness or support levels. Onsite salespeople can be very informative, as well.
  • Take Advantage of Sleep Trials: Virtually every major online mattress brand offers a sleep trial for customers to test out their mattress. Most sleep trials last at least 90 nights, and some last up to one year or longer. Sleep trials are beneficial because customers can determine whether or not the mattress will work for them in the long-term. Many brands offer free mattress returns (including full refunds), and some also offer mattress exchanges during the trial period.
Table of Contents