Our Research Process

At Tuck, we aim to deliver accurate, up-to-date product information and unbiased reviews based on verified consumer experiences. We’ve aggregated more than 200,000 owner and customer experiences from thousands of online sources to generate our data-based reviews of mattresses, pillows, and other sleep products and accessories — and we receive new feedback every day. Below is a detailed breakdown of our process for researching products, collecting data, and generating performance ratings.

Our Data Set

Sources

We draw on the following general sources to generate our product ratings:

  • Forums/Discussion Boards
    • Roughly 35 to 40% of our data is based on consumer experiences and reviews posted in web forums and discussion boards. We conduct an extensive search for each product review by reading legitimate threads within online communities of all sizes, then collect and verify each post to ensure it is valid and relevant to our research.
  • Retail Product Pages
    • Roughly 35 to 40% of our data comes from verified customer reviews posted to online product pages. We consider exclusively online retailers such as Amazon.com and Wayfair.com, as well as brick-and-mortar brands that sell sleep products and have a strong online presence, such as Target, Walmart, and Bed Bath & Beyond. We vet each review two times to ensure none of them are fake and that the author has not been compensated (financially or otherwise) for their feedback.
  • Product Review Websites
    • Roughly 20 to 30% of our data comes from sleep product review websites, depending on the specific brand and model. Fake and/or dishonest online review sites are rampant, particularly in the realm of sleep products. The owners of these sites often receive compensation for highlighting certain brands and recommending specific models. In order to provide the most accurate information, we avoid sites like these as a rule and narrow our focus on authentic review sites that provide objective, unaffiliated information (such as Consumer Reports). We also vet individual postings on larger review sites to ensure the author has not been compensated for their work or is affiliated with any existing product brands.
  •  Publicly Available Information
    • We never generate customer or performance ratings based on product descriptions or marketing claims that come directly from product manufacturers or brands. However, most of these companies provide detailed product specifications and company information that we use in our brand and model profiles. These details include:
      • Material composition
      • Country of manufacture
      • Available sizes
      • Product availability, including online and brick-and-mortar sellers
      • Current price-points for each available size
      • Length, width, and thickness dimensions
      • If applicable, product firmness
      • Care instructions
      • Weight
      • Company history, including years in business and contact information
      • Shipping and delivery policies
      • Sleep trial and return policies
      • Warranty information

What is NOT included in our data set?

  • Personal Testing
    • In the past, we have not personally tested mattresses, pillows, bedding, or sleep accessories. Rather than evaluating products based on one person’s subjective experience, we prefer to create rankings based on the largest, most valid sample size of owner and customer experiences. However, we eventually intend to add editorial elements to our review pages. These elements include video and photo reviews, which we plan to introduce in summer 2018. We will update our methodology accordingly as these new features are uploaded, so be sure to check back often for site updates.
  •  User-submitted Reviews
    • We encourage all Tuck.com visitors to share their mattress stories and experiences with us, and greatly appreciate your feedback. However, we do not incorporate reviews from our users into our rating system.

What Makes Us Unique?

  • We’re Comprehensive
    • Tuck.com offers complete coverage for all sleep products, from mattresses and bedding to alarm clocks, blackout curtains, and other sleep accessories. These products are subject to constant change in terms of pricing, availability, material composition, and other key factors that matter to consumers. Occasionally, we will not collect enough customer data to generate what we consider to be accurate product reviews. However, rest assured that whatever you find on Tuck is as much as — if not significantly more than — you’ll find elsewhere on the web.
  • We’re User-Friendly
    • Creating your optimal sleep environment is no easy feat considering the myriad of products that are available today. Mattresses, pillows, sheets, and bedside accessories all carry important considerations for any consumer, especially first-time buyers. Our comparison tool is straightforward and easy to use. We also offer an extensive selection of individual brand and model reviews to help you narrow down your choices, as well as research-based guides covering a wide range of sleep-related topics. To look up a specific topic, use the search tool found in the top right-hand corner.
  • Accuracy
    • Data accuracy is one of our highest priorities, and we do everything in our power to ensure the information on our site is correct, up-to-date, and reflective of consumer experiences. For this reason, we have established parameters for our rating process. In order to generate accurate ratings, we do the following:
      • We assign each reviewable product a specific baseline for customer experiences and unique sources based on feedback availability. For example, we require at least 60 verified customer experiences from at least four unique sources. Additionally, no individual source makes up more than 50% of the reviews we collect. If we are unable to collect sufficient consumer feedback, then we will withhold ratings for that brand or product until we have enough data. This information is prominently displayed at the top of each review page. If we have enough data, we will list the total number of verified experiences and unique sources. If we don’t have enough data, then we will state as such.
      • We vet each consumer review to ensure it meets our standards for quality. Some reviews do not contain enough information to verify if the author actually owns the product. In order to be included in our data set, the reviewer must demonstrate that he or she has owned the product for at least two weeks. Additionally, the review must have been published within the last six years. Reviews that do not meet these two criteria points will not be included in the data set.
  • We’re Unbiased and Unaffiliated
    • We want to stress this point in great detail, so we’ve created an editorial integrity policy that outlines how we collect information, generate money for the site, and communicate with different companies and brands. Please visit the page to learn the specifics and feel free to reach out if you have any questions.
  • We’re Here to Help!
    • Please contact us if you want to learn more about brand and products, sleep-related topics, or the site itself. A member of our sleep team will promptly respond to make sure all of your questions are answered. Day or night, rain or shine, we are committed to ensuring your experience on Tuck.com is informative and meaningful.

How to Use Our Mattress Comparison Engine

Our Criteria, explained:

  • Overall customer satisfaction rating: All satisfaction ratings are generated on a scale of 0% to 100%.
  • Sleep ratings: We keep our ratings system simple and calculate averages using the five-tier system outlined below:
    • Poor: 0.0 to 0.99
    • Fair: 1.0 to 1.99
    • Good: 2.0 to 2.99
    • Very Good: 3.0 to 3.99
    • Excellent: 4.0 to 4.99

The following performance factors are subject to ratings based on owner and customer experiences.

  • Sleep positions: Your experience with a mattress, pillow, or other sleep product often depends on your preferred sleep position. For each applicable product, we look at data from the following groups:
    • Side sleepers
    • Back sleepers
    • Stomach sleepers
    • Although we do not include ratings for combination sleepers (those who sleep in multiple positions), we use data from these sleepers based on their experiences in different positions.
  • Body weight: Like sleep position, your body weight may affect your experience with different sleep products. We’ve broken all weights into three groups:
    • Light: Less than 130 pounds
    • Average: 130 to 230 pounds
    • Heavy: More than 230 pounds

Please note that all sleep position and body weight ratings are based on the overall level of comfort and support reported by each individual subset. These ratings are subjective; your individual experience with a particular product may not reflect our overall findings related to your sleep position and body weight.

Next, we’ll look at the factors we’ve evaluated in our sleep ratings tables. The following factors are found in the ratings tables for multiple product types (mattresses, pillows, etc.)

  • Durability: This refers to how long the product maintains structure and provides comfort and support before it begins to deteriorate and develop indentations. As a point of reference, the average mattress lifespan is six to eight years; and the average pillow lifespan is two to three years.
  • Conforming: Some mattresses and pillows conform closely to the sleeper’s body. This helps align their spine and alleviate pressure points throughout the body. However, conforming ability also refers to how evenly the pressure relief is distributed.
  • Temperature neutrality: This refers to how hot or cold a product sleeps based on how much body heat it retains from the sleeper’s body. Several factors affect temperature neutrality, including thickness, material composition, and how well the product dissipates heat through airflow. The sleeper’s natural tendency to sleep hot or cold also plays a role.
  • Odor potential: Most new products emit chemical smells known as ‘off-gassing’ when they are removed from their packaging. Off-gassing odors are considered non-toxic and do not pose a safety risk to consumers, but the smells can be quite unpleasant. This data point refers to how strong and/or persistent a product’s off-gassing odors are.
  • Weight/ease of movement: Size and material composition can make sleep products heavier or lighter. When generating ratings for weight, we look at how much a product weighs compared to all similar models. A pillow that weighs 10 pounds may receive a ‘Poor’ or ‘Fair’ rating because it is heavier and more difficult to move compared to other pillows of its type, whereas a 60-pound mattress may receive a rating of ‘Excellent’ or ‘Very Good’ because it is much lighter than the average mattress.

The following performance factors are evaluated in our mattress reviews only:

  • Motion isolation: This refers to how effectively the bed’s surface absorbs motion transfer when someone gets up or shifts positions, and then prevents that transfer from spreading to other areas of the mattress. Motion isolation is particularly important to couples and other people who share a bed with someone else, since sleep disruptions are commonly reported with mattresses that do not minimize motion transfer.
  • Sex: Mattresses that are bouncier and more responsive tend to be better for sex, according to general consensus. Mattresses that are not responsive may cause couples to sink too deeply, which can negatively affect sex.
  • Edge support: In some cases, mattresses may begin to sink around the edges — particularly in places where people sit when they get out of bed. This sinkage (also known as roll-off) is more prominent with some mattress types than others.
  • Noise: Some mattresses — particularly those with steel springs or coils — can be quite noisy when bearing weight. Others are virtually silent. Material composition is usually the deciding factor when it comes to noise potential.

The following performance factors are included in sleep ratings tables for pillows only:

  • Firmness options: Every sleeper has a different firmness preference when it comes to pillows. Some pillow manufacturers offer a wide range of firmness options, while others only carry one or two.
  • Shape retention: The difference between a pillow with a full, consistent shape and one that flattens and requires constant fluffing is quite significant. This data point refers to how well a pillow maintains its shape, as well as the maintenance required to fluff it back to its original structure.
  • Moldability: Many people prefer to cuddle with a pillow while they sleep, and some models are more suitable for nighttime snuggling than others. When we evaluate moldability, we look at whether the pillow is soft or firm, as well as how compact it becomes when scrunched.
  • Ease of cleaning: For the purposes of this site, we consider a pillow relatively easy to clean if it can be machine-washed and machine- or air-dried. Pillows that require spot cleaning or professional (dry) cleaning are considered more difficult to clean. Please note that some pillow types cannot be machine-washed or machine-dried by design.

Lastly, the comparison engine incorporates the following product factors. Unlike those listed above, these factors are not subject to ratings based on customer experiences.

  • Product type: Type refers to material composition only. By selecting one of the type options, you will generate a comparison for all products that fit that criteria. For instance, let’s say you select ‘latex’ in the mattress comparison. This will generate a comparison for all models that qualify as ‘latex mattresses’ with latex comfort layers and latex/foam support cores. This will not include other mattress types (such as hybrids) that feature one or two individual latex layers.
  • Firmness: All mattresses and pillows have a firmness that falls between 1 (least firm) and 10 (firmest). We obtain this information from product manufacturers and customer reviews, but we do not ‘rate’ firmness.
  • Price: Our product pages list prices for all sizes and product options. Additionally, our mattress review pages feature a graph comparing that brand/model’s price against industry averages. For this graph, we use the Queen size only. We never use temporary sales or discounts to generate prices.

Why is this product missing some data/rankings?

On some pages, you will find certain data points have been left blank or listed as not available (N/A). This indicates we do not have enough customer experience data to make an assertion about that particular data point.

Please check back for updates and feel free to contact us if you have additional questions.

Where Should You Start?

We recommend beginning with our guides to product types, brands, and models. This will help you understand what to expect in terms of price-point, sleep quality, and customer experience based on your height, weight, and preferred sleep position.

Next, use our comparison engine to narrow down your choices based on type and brand, price, firmness, and customer satisfaction rating.

Once you’ve gathered the information you need, we encourage you to visit the product’s official page on the company’s website. If the product you want is exclusively sold in brick-and-mortar stores, make notes about the brands and models that interest you the most before making an in-store visit.

Have Questions/Comments/Concerns?

See something inaccurate or that needs to be updated?

Please reach out to us! We’re here at all hours of the day and want to make sure you get the information you need so let us know how we can help.

Want to share a review of your experience with a particular mattress?

Visit our submit a product review page and give us a detailed account. Although we don’t currently use user-submitted reviews these for our customer satisfaction scoring and sleep ratings, we still want to hear about your personal experience.