Brooklyn Bedding Pillow Reviews

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which may earn us a commission. Learn more here.

Overview

Brooklyn Bedding first came to life as a store on Amazon. After figuring out the key to a successful, self-manufactured bed-in-a-box mattress business, the Arizona brand soon moved to its own website. Since then, Brooklyn Bedding has found tremendous success thanks to their robust mattress lineup and accessories.

Among the company’s bed accessories, Brooklyn Bedding offers four distinct pillows for sale: the Talalay Latex Pillow, Luxury Cooling Pillow, Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow, and Premium Shredded Foam Pillow.

  • Talalay Latex Pillow: This pillow comes filled with American-made Talalay latex and encased in an organic cotton cover that’s moisture-wicking and antimicrobial. The cover helps to promote a dry and hygienic sleep environment. As for its Talalay latex interior, it offers up to seven times more airflow than other latex foams, making Brooklyn Bedding’s Talalay Latex Pillow highly breathable and very cooling. This pillow works for back, side, and stomach sleepers.
  • Luxury Cooling Pillow: This exquisite pillow is made of open cell, fast response memory foam that’s surrounded by a premium-quality circular-knit cover. It also features a dual action cooling system. The cooling gel draws heat away from the pillow surface. Meanwhile, the pin core ventilation provides an increase in airflow. Additionally, the pillow is naturally antimicrobial and highly resistant to allergens, mold, bacteria, and dust mites. The Luxury Cooling Pillow offers gentle, near instantaneous support to your head, neck, and shoulders. The low loft version is great for stomach sleepers, while side sleepers will likely prefer the high loft option.
  • Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow: This pillow is made from a moldable memory foam and encased in a plush knit cover. It easily conforms to support your head and neck region and the pin core ventilation provides increased airflow that lets you sleep cool. With its rounded edges and more traditional look, the Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow is an ideal alternative to down and feather pillows.
  • Premium Shredded Foam Pillow: The Premium Shredded Foam pillow comes with a zippable antimicrobial cover. Inside is a blend of shredded high-quality foam. The pillow arrives overstuffed so that you can remove as much foam as you’d like to adjust the loft. The pillow’s deconstructed foam bits are infused with a cooling gel, which lets it draw heat away from your head and neck while you sleep. Overall, it’s a pillow that’s easy to customize with a sleep surface that allows you to stay cool and comfortable all night.

As you can see, Brooklyn Bedding offers a series of pillows that appeals to a variety of needs. All of their pillows sleep cool and are available in queen and king sizes.

Read on to gain more insight into Brooklyn Bedding Pillows and what they have to offer customers.

Pros
  • Brooklyn Bedding pillows tend to be very breathable and cooling, so overheating won’t be a problem.
  • These pillows offer optimal head, neck, and shoulder support.
  • The covers are machine washable.
  • The prices range, so there is a pillow option for every budget.
  • The covers are antimicrobial, hypoallergenic, and tend to be moisture wicking.
Cons
  • They’re only available in queen and king sizes, so the sizing options are limited.
  • Although the covers are machine washable, pillow inserts are not.
  • Aside from the adjustable shredded pillow, limiting buyers to a “high” or “low” loft pillow might not work for sleepers who fall between the two choices and don’t find either option completely satisfying.

Informing Our Review

1,879 verified customer experiences — 12 hours of testing — 4 expert consultations

Recommendations

By understanding your individual needs, you’ll be better informed about whether Brooklyn Bedding Pillows are right for you. Below we share how a sleeper might feel about each type of Brooklyn Bedding Pillow based on key factors.

Talalay Latex Pillow Sleep Position Lightweight Sleeper (less than 130 lbs) Average Weight Sleeper Rating (130 to 230 lbs) Heavyweight Sleeper Rating (More than 230 lbs)
Medium-Firm Side Good Very Good Good
Back Good Very Good Good
Stomach Good Good Good

 

Luxury Cooling Pillow Sleep Position Lightweight Sleeper (less than 130 lbs) Average Weight Sleeper Rating (130 to 230 lbs) Heavyweight Sleeper Rating (More than 230 lbs)
Medium-Firm Side Good Good Good
Back Good Good Good
Stomach Good Good Good

 

Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow Sleep Position Lightweight Sleeper (less than 130 lbs) Average Weight Sleeper Rating (130 to 230 lbs) Heavyweight Sleeper Rating (More than 230 lbs)
Medium-Firm Side Good Good Good
Back Good Good Good
Stomach Good Good Good

 

Premium Shredded Foam Pillow Sleep Position Lightweight Sleeper (less than 130 lbs) Average Weight Sleeper Rating (130 to 230 lbs) Heavyweight Sleeper Rating (More than 230 lbs)
Varies with adjustment of foam Side Good Good Good
Back Good Good Good
Stomach Fair Fair Fair

Brooklyn Bedding Pillows are designed to appeal to as wide a group of sleepers as possible. The low loft pillows work for stomach sleepers while the high loft option tends to be preferred by side sleepers. Back sleepers should feel comfortable with either loft depending on their own comfort preferences.

If you prefer a truly customizable sleep experience, the Premium Shredded Foam Pillow is your best option. You can manually raise or lower the loft level by adding or removing the foam, making it the Brooklyn Bedding Pillow that provides the most individualized sleep experience.

Ratings

Before you buy a pillow, it’s important to research what users are saying. In the following table, we summarized what we learned from comments from by sleepers who previously bought a Brooklyn Bedding Pillow.

Talalay Latex Pillow

Category Criteria Brooklyn Bedding Rating What Brooklyn Bedding Users Say
Category

Durability

Criteria

The average pillow will perform for two to three years before a replacement is needed. A pillow’s expected lifespan is typically tied to its material composition.

Rating

N/A

What Buyers Say

Because this pillow was only released a couple of months prior to this review, not enough time has passed to accurately gauge how durable it is.

Category

Firmness Options

Criteria

Pillows sold with one firmness option can be limiting for customers whose preferences fall outside that setting, but many pillows sold today are available in multiple firmness designs.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Although it came with two loft options, overall there was a lack of range for firmness. Some users found the pillows to either be too firm or not firm enough.

Category

Shape Retention

Criteria

Some pillows flatten quickly and require frequent fluffing in order to retain a full shape, while other models maintain a full shape with minimal maintenance.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Buyers felt it held its shape really well without too many adjustments.

Category

Moldability

Criteria

Pillows that are relatively moldable are optimal for sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow during the night, as well as those who like to place support pillows beneath their legs or between their knees.

Rating

Poor

What Buyers Say

Users didn’t consider this to be a particularly fluffable type of pillow.

Category

Conforming

Criteria

Pillows that conform closely to the sleeper’s head, neck, and shoulders typically alleviate more aches and pains than those that conform less.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

It easily conforms to the contours of your head, neck and shoulder.

Category

Temperature Neutrality

Criteria

Some pillows feature breathable cover materials and good airflow throughout the interior, which allow them to sleep cooler than others.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

The pillow’s Talalay Latex is several times more breathable than other latex foams; pushing on the pillow surface let users feel a rush of cooling air.

Category

Odor Potential

Criteria

In addition to off-gassing odors, which often occur when pillows are new, some models are filled with materials that emit strong smells.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

There was a slight odor at first, but users said it soon went away.

Category

Weight

Criteria

Most pillows are relatively light, but heavier models can be difficult to lift and adjust during the night.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users found it to be lightweight and comfortable.

Category

Ease of Cleaning

Criteria

Many pillows sold today can be washed or dried in machines, but others require more expensive and/or time-consuming care measures such as spot cleaning or dry cleaning.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

The zipper that lets the cover get removed for cleaning is useful, but some found it’s positioning uncomfortable. That aside, there were no complaints about cleaning.

Luxury Cooling Pillow

Category Criteria Brooklyn Bedding Rating What Brooklyn Bedding Users Say
Category

Durability

Criteria

The average pillow will perform for two to three years before a replacement is needed. A pillow’s expected lifespan is typically tied to its material composition.

Rating

N/A

What Buyers Say

Because this pillow was only released a couple of months prior to this review, not enough time has passed to accurately gauge how durable it is.

Category

Firmness Options

Criteria

Pillows sold with one firmness option can be limiting for customers whose preferences fall outside that setting, but many pillows sold today are available in multiple firmness designs.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Users would have appreciated a wider firmness range for these pillows.

Category

Shape Retention

Criteria

Some pillows flatten quickly and require frequent fluffing in order to retain a full shape, while other models maintain a full shape with minimal maintenance.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Customers didn’t raise issues about shape retention.

Category

Moldability

Criteria

Pillows that are relatively moldable are optimal for sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow during the night, as well as those who like to place support pillows beneath their legs or between their knees.

Rating

Poor

What Buyers Say

Although it contours well, it’s not designed to be particularly fluffable.

Category

Conforming

Criteria

Pillows that conform closely to the sleeper’s head, neck, and shoulders typically alleviate more aches and pains than those that conform less.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users said pillow conforms well to the head, neck, and shoulder area.

Category

Temperature Neutrality

Criteria

Some pillows feature breathable cover materials and good airflow throughout the interior, which allow them to sleep cooler than others.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

Users say they felt cool immediately and didn’t have issues with overheating.

Category

Odor Potential

Criteria

In addition to off-gassing odors, which often occur when pillows are new, some models are filled with materials that emit strong smells.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Light off-gassing in the beginning, but it typically wasn’t a problem for customers.

Category

Weight

Criteria

Most pillows are relatively light, but heavier models can be difficult to lift and adjust during the night.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

It’s a nice light pillow that’s designed to be airy and cool.

Category

Ease of Cleaning

Criteria

Many pillows sold today can be washed or dried in machines, but others require more expensive and/or time-consuming care measures such as spot cleaning or dry cleaning.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Its removable cover was easy to wash.

Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow

Category Criteria Brooklyn Bedding Rating What Brooklyn Bedding Users Say
Category

Durability

Criteria

The average pillow will perform for two to three years before a replacement is needed. A pillow’s expected lifespan is typically tied to its material composition.

Rating

N/A

What Buyers Say

Because this pillow was only released a couple of months prior to this review, not enough time has passed to accurately gauge how durable it is.

Category

Firmness Options

Criteria

Pillows sold with one firmness option can be limiting for customers whose preferences fall outside that setting, but many pillows sold today are available in multiple firmness designs.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Not necessarily a wide enough range of firmness for customers.

Category

Shape Retention

Criteria

Some pillows flatten quickly and require frequent fluffing in order to retain a full shape, while other models maintain a full shape with minimal maintenance.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Customers said it held its shape.

Category

Moldability

Criteria

Pillows that are relatively moldable are optimal for sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow during the night, as well as those who like to place support pillows beneath their legs or between their knees.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

The pillow comes with a very moldable memory foam, that customer soft and even ‘mushy’ but also very supportive.

Category

Conforming

Criteria

Pillows that conform closely to the sleeper’s head, neck, and shoulders typically alleviate more aches and pains than those that conform less.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users felt it conformed well to their head and neck area.

Category

Temperature Neutrality

Criteria

Some pillows feature breathable cover materials and good airflow throughout the interior, which allow them to sleep cooler than others.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users liked the pillow’s temperature neutrality, it kept them cool all night.

Category

Odor Potential

Criteria

In addition to off-gassing odors, which often occur when pillows are new, some models are filled with materials that emit strong smells.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Some off-gassing at first, but users said it went away within a day or so.

Category

Weight

Criteria

Most pillows are relatively light, but heavier models can be difficult to lift and adjust during the night.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users didn’t find it particularly heavy.

Category

Ease of Cleaning

Criteria

Many pillows sold today can be washed or dried in machines, but others require more expensive and/or time-consuming care measures such as spot cleaning or dry cleaning.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Customers didn’t have issues removing and cleaning the cover.

Premium Shredded Foam Pillow

Category Criteria Brooklyn Bedding Rating What Brooklyn Bedding Users Say
Category

Durability

Criteria

The average pillow will perform for two to three years before a replacement is needed. A pillow’s expected lifespan is typically tied to its material composition.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Users seem to feel that the pillow, while great at first, doesn’t hold up well after so many months, falling just shy of a year before needing to be replaced. As such, it falls short of the recommended durability level of two to three years.

Category

Firmness Options

Criteria

Pillows sold with one firmness option can be limiting for customers whose preferences fall outside that setting, but many pillows sold today are available in multiple firmness designs.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

It arrives overstuffed and very firm, but by carefully adjusting the filling, you can bring the pillow to your preferred loft and firmness level.

Category

Shape Retention

Criteria

Some pillows flatten quickly and require frequent fluffing in order to retain a full shape, while other models maintain a full shape with minimal maintenance.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Customers found that it held onto its original shape well enough.

Category

Moldability

Criteria

Pillows that are relatively moldable are optimal for sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow during the night, as well as those who like to place support pillows beneath their legs or between their knees.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users appreciated that you can fluff and adjust this pillow.

Category

Conforming

Criteria

Pillows that conform closely to the sleeper’s head, neck, and shoulders typically alleviate more aches and pains than those that conform less.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Users said it conformed well to their head and neck area when they laid on it.

Category

Temperature Neutrality

Criteria

Some pillows feature breathable cover materials and good airflow throughout the interior, which allow them to sleep cooler than others.

Rating

Very Good

What Buyers Say

Customers found that it slept very cool through the night.

Category

Odor Potential

Criteria

In addition to off-gassing odors, which often occur when pillows are new, some models are filled with materials that emit strong smells.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Users complained of a “chemical smell” out of the box that was a bit off-putting. It went away for some but others couldn’t get rid of it.

Category

Weight

Criteria

Most pillows are relatively light, but heavier models can be difficult to lift and adjust during the night.

Rating

Fair

What Buyers Say

Users definitely felt the weight of this pillow when it arrived overstuffed, but removing foam can affect the weightiness of it.

Category

Ease of Cleaning

Criteria

Many pillows sold today can be washed or dried in machines, but others require more expensive and/or time-consuming care measures such as spot cleaning or dry cleaning.

Rating

Good

What Buyers Say

Customers found it easy to clean.

Overall, customers found the pillows to be conforming, comfortable, and cooling. The exception might be the Premium Shredded Foam Pillow, which arrives overstuffed. If customers did not remove the excess foam filling to make it suit their personal comfort level, then they were more likely to complain about how uncomfortable it was. The only other issue with the Premium Shredded Foam Pillow was with the odor. After airing the pillow out for about a day, most buyers found the pillow’s “chemical smell” soon went away.

What You Need to Know about Brooklyn Bedding Pillows

Product Construction & Firmness

Brooklyn Bedding Pillows are all designed with a few common concerns in mind. For instance, Brooklyn Bedding covers are designed to be antimicrobial as well as resistant to allergens, dust mites, and bacteria. Moreover, the materials for making the pillows are organic and natural, with an emphasis on eco-friendliness.

Product Name Firmness Options Loft Interior Components Cover Components
Talalay Latex Pillow ‘Medium-Firm’ 7″ Talalay latex foam Organic-cotton
Luxury Cooling Pillow ‘Firm’ 4.5″ to 6″ Open-cell, fast response memory foam Premium circular knit cover
Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow ‘Firm’ 7.8″ Moldable memory foam Luxury knit cover
Premium Shredded Pillow ‘Firm’ 7″ Blended foam materials, shredded Bamboo

While all Brooklyn Bedding Pillows have some hypoallergenic qualities, the Talalay Latex Pillow is described as the best choice for sleepers with allergies. This type of latex goes through about five stages of washing to ensure that its free of the proteins that are common in latex allergies. This material also provides up to seven times more airflow than other types of latex foam, which makes the Talalay Latex Pillow feel very airy and cool when you lay your head on it. The material is firm enough to offer good support to your head and neck with contouring that promotes proper spine alignment.

Brooklyn Bedding’s Luxury Cooling Pillow offers high-quality cooling in a few ways. The foam is infused with a cooling gel substance that counters memory foam’s natural tendency to feel hot. The pillow includes the added dual punch of copper and graphite, both which draw heat away from the pillow’s surface. The pillow’s pin core ventilation increases airflow. The pillow even makes use of copper’s natural antimicrobial properties.

The Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow also features a pin core ventilation system for increased airflow. The difference is that its made of a more moldable memory foam. It also functions as a reliable alternative to down or feather pillows.

The Shredded Memory Foam Pillow comes overstuffed with a blend of foam materials. It’s important to know you’re not necessarily expected to sleep on the pillow as it arrives. The reason the pillow has more foam than it needs is to make sure you can adjust the pillow by removing filling until the pillow is at a comfortable loft. The deconstructed foam filling is infused with cooling gel, so when you do find your best sleeping loft, you’ll sleep as cool as possible.

Pricing & Sizing

The Brooklyn Bedding Pillow is available in king and queen sizes. Please read the following tables for more specific details about sizing and pricing.

Talalay Latex Pillow

Size Dimensions Loft Price
Queen 26.5” x 16” 7” $89.00
King 35” x 16” 7” $99.00

Luxury Cooling Pillow

Size Dimensions Loft Price
Queen 27” x 18” 4.5” to 6” $129.00
King 32” x 18” 4.5” to 6” $149.00

Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow

Size Dimensions Loft Price
Queen 16” x 7.8” 7.8” $69.00
King 16” x 7.8” 7.8” $79.00

Premium Shredded Pillows

Size Dimensions Loft Price
Queen 29” x 16” 7” $44.00
King 34” x 16” 7” $49.00

Delivery & Product Care

Delivery Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping.
Product Care Machine washable cover, but the insert is “spot clean only.”
Full delivery and product care details

Delivery

Where Can The Pillow Be Shipped?: Brooklyn Bedding ships directly to customers in the United States, including Hawaii and Alaska, and Canada. If you live outside of this region, the company recommends looking into “Freight Forward Services,” as they are willing to ship to these companies in the United States. These companies can then, in turn, ship Brooklyn Bedding orders to international customers.

Delivery Fee: Standard shipping is free for customers located in the contiguous United States. However, customers in Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada will have to pay a shipping fee.

Delivery Policy: The Brooklyn Bedding store delivery policy is as follows:

Orders ship within one to two days of your purchase. Brooklyn Bedding typically ships using FedEx Ground, and orders can take three to five days to arrive. Customers cannot modify an order once it has shipped nor can they cancel a shipped order. Attempting to cancel a non-shipped order may make you subject to a $60 cancellation fee. It’s possible to delay a shipment by calling the Brooklyn Bedding customer service team at 1-888-210-8751. They can make sure your order arrives within one to two days of a requested date. However, it’s not possible for Brooklyn Bedding to guarantee an order will arrive on an exact date.

Caring for Your Brooklyn Bedding Pillow

Instructions For First Time Use: It’s recommended that customers air the pillows out for at least a few hours after they arrive to help ventilate them and remove any lingering chemical odors.

You can machine wash the cover of a Brooklyn Bedding Pillow. Just use a gentle wash setting and then either tumble dry on a low setting or lay flat to dry. With the Talalay, Luxury Cooling, or Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow, remove the insert to clean the cover. For the Premium Shredded Foam Pillow, empty the foam filling into a plastic bag before attempting to clean the cover.

The pillow inserts are not machine washable; any insert stains should get spot-cleaned.

Sleep Trial & Warranty

Sleep trial 30-night trial
Warranty Three-year warranty
Full trial period and warranty details

Trial Period and Guarantee

A Brooklyn Bedding Pillow is covered by a 30-night trial period. If you purchase a pillow, but find that it’s not to your liking, you can return it for a full-refund.

Warranty

Brooklyn Bedding Pillows are backed by a three-year warranty that covers any defects in the material..

Similar Pillow Options

In the table below we compare and contrast the Brooklyn Bedding Pillow with similar pillows currently available for purchase.

Brooklyn Bedding Pillow Layla Helix Tuft & Needle

Model(s)

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding Pillow

Layla Pillow

Helix Pillow
Helix Ultra-Cool Pillow
Helix Wedge Pillow

T&N Pillow

Pillow Type

Brooklyn Bedding

Talalay latex (Talalay Latex Pillow), open cell memory foam (Luxury Cooling Pillow), moldable memory foam (Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow), premium shredded memory foam (Premium Shredded Foam Pillow)

Shredded memory foam and kapok tree fibers

Memory foam and down alternative (Helix Pillow/Ultra-Cool Pillow)
Gel memory foam and polyfoam (Helix Wedge Pillow)

Charcoal-infused polyfoam

Cover

Brooklyn Bedding

Organic cotton (Talalay Latex Pillow), premium circular knit cover (Luxury Cooling Pillow), luxury knit cover (Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow), bamboo cover (Shredded Memory Foam Pillow)

Polyester, viscose, and Lycra® spandex

Tencel® lyocell and polyester blend (Helix Pillow)
Polyester and polyethylene blend (Helix Ultra-Cool Pillow)
Rayon and polyester blend (Helix Wedge Pillow)

Polyester

Price Range (est.)

Brooklyn Bedding

$89 to $99(Talalay Latex Pillow), $129 to $149 (Luxury Cooling Pillow), $69 to $79 (Ventilated Memory Foam Pillow), $44 to $49 (Premium Shredded Foam Pillow)

$74 (Standard)
$94 (King)

$85 to $99 (Helix Pillow)
$115 to $129 (Helix Ultra-Cool Pillow)
$95 (Helix Wedge Pillow)

$75 (Standard)
$100 (King)

Loft Range

Brooklyn Bedding

7” for insert pillows; the shredded foam pillow has an adjustable loft.

4″ (both sizes)

Adjustable loft (Helix Pillow/Ultra-Cool Pillow)
10″ (Helix Wedge Pillow)

5″ (both sizes)

Firmness Options

Brooklyn Bedding

‘Medium Firm’

‘Medium Soft’

‘Medium Soft’ to ‘Medium Firm’ (Helix Pillow/Ultra-Cool Pillow)
‘Medium Firm’ (Helix Wedge Pillow)

‘Medium’

Availability

Brooklyn Bedding

Online and
In-store

Online

Online (all pillows)

Online
In-store

Sleep Trial

Brooklyn Bedding

30 nights

120 nights

100 nights (all pillows)

100 nights

Warranty Length

Brooklyn Bedding

3 years

5 years

3 years (Helix Pillow/Ultra-Cool Pillow)
1 year (Helix Wedge Pillow)

3 years

Company Information

Customer Service

8 out of 10 customers have had a positive experience with Brooklyn Bedding, irrespective of whether or not they liked their pillows.

Company History

Brooklyn Bedding founder John Merwin began selling bed-in-a-box mattresses in 2008. He and brother Rob moved to their website a short while later.

Physical Stores

Brooklyn Bedding mattresses and bed accessories are available online and in showrooms located throughout the state of Arizona and well as in Utah, Illinois, Minnesota, Montana, and New York.

Contact Brooklyn Bedding

Email | (888) 210-8751 | brooklynbedding.com

Find Brooklyn Bedding on Social Media

Instagram | Facebook  | Twitter