Simmons Beautyrest Mattress Reviews

Last updated on

Based on 3,513 verified customer experiences from 257 unique sources.

 

What You Need to Know about Simmons Beautyrest Mattresses

Mattress Type and Components:

  • Simmons Bedding Company offers innerspring and hybrid mattresses under the Beautyrest product name as part of three exclusive collections.
  • The Black Collection features innerspring mattresses with an above-average price-point. Some models are available in multiple firmness ratings. It currently features the following models (ordered by price from highest to lowest):
    • The Tatiana features a comfort layer with a top layer of gel memory foam, second layer of standard memory foam, a third layer of latex, and a microcoil bottom layer. The support core is designed with pocketed coils encased in edge support polyfoam.
    • The Sonya has a comfort layer with a top layer of memory foam, a middle layer of latex, and a microcoil bottom layer. The support core features pocketed coils with a polyfoam encasement.
    • The Natasha features a comfort layer with a layer of standard memory foam, followed by a latex bottom layer; the ‘Plush’ option also features a top layer of gel memory foam. The pocketed coil support core is encased in edge support polyfoam.
    • Like the Natasha, the Mariela has a comfort layer with layers of standard memory foam and latex; the ‘Plush’ option also features a top layer of gel memory foam. The support core has pocketed coils encased in edge support polyfoam.
    • The Katarina Pillow Top has a comfort layer with a top layer of standard memory foam and a bottom layer of gel memory foam. The support core foam-encased pocketed coils.
    • The Desiree has a memory foam comfort layer and a pocketed coil support core encased in edge support polyfoam.  
    • The Calista is designed with a memory foam comfort layer and a pocketed coil support core with a polyfoam encasement.
  • The Platinum Collection features innerspring and hybrid mattresses with a mid-range price-point. Some models are available in multiple firmness ratings; the current selection is listed below (ordered by price from highest to lowest):
    • The Quinn hybrid features a comfort layer with four components: a top layer of standard memory foam, a second layer of high-density memory foam, a third layer of standard memory foam, and a latex bottom layer. The support core features pocketed coils with a polyfoam encasement.
    • The Maddie hybrid has a comfort layer with two standard memory foam top layers, followed by a third layer of gel memory foam and a bottom layer of latex. This model also features a pocketed coil support core encased in edge support polyfoam.
    • The Bryson hybrid is constructed with three memory foam layers in the comfort layer, followed by a bottom latex layer. The support core features pocketed coils encased in polyfoam.
    • Like the Bryson, the Austin features a comfort layer with three memory foam top layers and a latex bottom layer. The pocketed coil support core is encased in polyfoam.
    • The Katherine Pillow Top innerspring has a comfort layer with a gel memory foam top layer, a standard memory foam middle layer, and a polyfoam bottom layer. The support core features pocketed coils encased in polyfoam.
    • The Gabriella Pillow Top innerspring is designed with a comfort layer with a top layer of gel memory foam and a bottom layer of standard memory foam. The pocketed coil support core is encased in edge support polyfoam.
    • The Brittany innerspring features a gel memory foam and standard memory foam comfort layer in the Plush and Luxury Firm settings, and a polyfoam comfort layer for the Firm setting. In all settings, the support core features pocketed coils encased in polyfoam.
    • The Amberlyn innerspring features a polyfoam comfort layer with a memory foam center and a pocketed coil support core with a polyfoam encasement.
  • The Silver Collection features innerspring and hybrid mattresses with a below-average price-point. Some models are available in multiple firmness ratings. The current lineup is outlined below (listed by price from highest to lowest):
    • The Harbour Beach hybrid has a comfort layer with a top layer of standard memory foam, a middle layer of gel memory foam, and a bottom layer of standard memory foam. The support core features pocketed coils.
    • The Cascade Mist hybrid features a comfort layer with a standard memory foam and gel memory foam top layers, and a standard memory foam bottom layer. This model also features a pocketed coil support core.
    • The Austin Reef hybrid has a comfort layer with a top layer of standard memory foam, a middle layer of gel memory foam and a polyfoam bottom layer, as well as a pocketed coil support core.
    • The Beachwood hybrid has a comfort layer with top and bottom memory foam layers, and a polyfoam middle layer. The support core is constructed with pocketed coils.
    • The Charcoal Coast Pillow Top innerspring features a comfort layer with two top layers of polyfoam, followed by a third layer of memory foam and a microcoil layer. The support core has pocketed coils.
    • The Charcoal Coast innerspring has a comfort layer has two top layers of polyfoam, a third layer of gel memory foam, and a final microcoil layer. The support core features pocketed coils.
    • The Open Seas Pillow Top innerspring has a comfort layer with two top layers of polyfoam, followed by a third layer of gel memory foam and a bottom polyfoam layer. The support core has pocketed coils.
    • The Open Seas innerspring features two top polyfoam layers in the comfort layer, followed by a bottom layer of gel memory foam. The support core features pocketed coils.
    • The Tidewater has a comfort layer with top and bottom polyfoam layers surrounding a middle layer of gel memory foam. The support core is designed with pocketed coils.
  • Simmons Bedding Company does not disclose the composition of any mattress covers.

Pros:

  • Simmons Beautyrest currently offers 24 different innerspring and hybrid mattress models, half of which are available in multiple firmness settings. This extensive selection should accommodate a wide range of sleepers.
  • A large number of owners claim Simmons Beautyrest mattresses offer above-average edge support, and have a responsive surface that makes them better for sex.
  • Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are available at hundreds of brick-and-mortar locations across the country.

Cons:

  • The chief performance complaints among owners include a below-average lifespan, minimal motion isolation, and more off-gassing than other innersprings and hybrids.
  • Most Simmons Beautyrest mattresses have an above-average price-point compared to comparable innersprings and hybrids.
  • Simmons Bedding Company does not disclose most mattress specifications or measurements, making it hard for consumers to research individual models based on factors like foam density, comfort layer thickness, and cover composition.

Product and Price Range: Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are available in seven sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full, Queen, King, and California King; please note that some models may not come in all sizes. The price of a Simmons Beautyrest mattress will vary by size and selected model; a full pricing chart is featured in the next section. All Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are manufactured in the United States.

Customer Satisfaction Rating: 62 to 67 (varies by model)
Calculated from: 3,513 customer experiences from 257 individual sources.
Amazon rating: 2.4 to 5.0 (varies by model)
BBB rating: B

 

Simmons Beautyrest Price Comparison

Simmons Beautyrest Pricing and Delivery Details

SizeDimensions Height RangeAvailability Notes
Twin35W” x 75L”13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)
Not available for Platinum Hybrids or Black Collection
Twin Extra Long (XL)35W” x 80L”12 1/2″ to 18 1/2″ (Black)
13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)
Full40W” x 75L”12 1/2″ to 18 1/2″ (Black)
13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)
Full Extra Long (XL)40W” x 80L”11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)Only available for Silver Innersprings
Queen60W” x 80L”12 1/2″ to 18 1/2″ (Black)
13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)
King76W” x 80L”12 1/2″ to 18 1/2″ (Black)
13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)
California King72W” x 84L”12 1/2″ to 18 1/2″ (Black)
13″ to 16″ (Platinum)
11″ to 15 1/2″ (Silver)

Prices for Simmons Beautyrest mattresses will vary by third-party seller; for this reason, flat price rates are not available for selected mattress models in any size. The next table looks at base queen-size prices for all current Simmons Beautyrest mattresses.

Mattress CollectionMattress ModelStarting Price (Queen Size)
Black (All Innerspring)Tatiana$4,999
Sonya$3,999
Natasha$2,999
Mariela$2,799
Katarina Pillow Top$2,599
Desiree$2,299
Calista$1,999
PlatinumQuinn (Hybrid)$3,199
Maddie (Hybrid)$2,999
Bryson (Hybrid)$2,699
Austin (Hybrid)$2,499
Katherine Pillow Top (Innerspring)$1,999
Gabriella Pillow Top (Innerspring)$1,699
Brittany (Innerspring)$1,599
Amberlyn (Innerspring)$1,499
SilverHarbour Beach (Hybrid)$2,099
Cascade Mist (Hybrid)$1,899
Austin Reef (Hybrid)$1,699
Beachwood (Hybrid)$1,499
Charcoal Coast Pillow Top (Innerspring)$1,299
Charcoal Coast (Innerspring)$1,099
Open Seas Pillow Top (Innerspring)$999
Open Seas (Innerspring)$899
Tidewater (Innerspring)$799

Delivery Policy: Innerspring and hybrid mattresses from Simmons Bedding Company are exclusively available for purchase at brick-and-mortar locations. Customers should defer to the delivery policy of the retailer where they purchase their mattress.

Old Mattress Removal: Simmons Bedding Company does not offer old mattress removal services. Customers should inquire about old mattress removal from the retailer where they purchase their Simmons Beautyrest model.
Availability: Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are available at numerous brick-and-mortar retail locations across the country. They are also sold on Amazon.com and other online retail sites, but are not available for purchase on the Simmons Beautyrest website.

 

Simmons Beautyrest Product Specifications and Firmness

The firmness rating of a Simmons Beautyrest mattress will vary by selected model; some models are available in multiple firmness sizes, as indicated in the table below. Simmons Bedding Company does not disclose specific layer measurements, foam density, or cover composition for any mattresses.

Simmons Beautyrest CollectionMattress ModelFirmness RatingThicknessSupport Core ComponentsComfort Layer ComponentsCover Components
Black Tatiana3.5 (Ultra Plush)18 1/2″Pocketed Coils (850 or More)
Foam Encasement
Memory Foam
Gel Memory Foam
Polyfoam
Latex (Select Models)
Minicoils (Select Models)
Not Disclosed
Sonya5 (Luxury Firm)18″
Natasha4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
16″
Mariela5 (Luxury Firm)
7.5 (Extra Firm)
14″ to 15″
Katarina Pillow Top4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
15″
Desiree4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
13 1/2″
Calista7.5 (Extra Firm)12 1/2″
Platinum HybridQuinn3.5 (Ultra Plush)15 1/2″Pocketed Coils (1,000)
Foam Encasement
Memory Foam
Gel Memory Foam
Latex (Select Models)
Not Disclosed
Maddie5 (Luxury Firm)15″
Bryson4 (Plush)15″
Austin5 (Luxury Firm)14 1/2″
Platinum InnerspringKatherine Pillow Top4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
16″Pocketed Coils (1,000)
Foam Encasement
Memory Foam
Polyfoam
Gel Memory Foam (Select Models)
Gel Polyfoam (Select Models)
Not Disclosed
Gabriella Pillow Top4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
14 to 14 1/2″
Brittany4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
6.5 (Firm)
13 1/2″ to 14 1/2″
Amberlyn7.5 (Extra Firm)13″
Silver HybridHarbour Beach3.5 (Ultra Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
14″Pocketed Coils (800 or More)Gel Memory Foam
Gel Polyfoam
Polyfoam
Memory Foam (Select Models)
Minicoils (Select models)
Not Disclosed
Cascade Mist6.5 (Firm)13 1/2″
Austin Reef4 (Plush)13″
Beachwood5 (Luxury Firm)12 1/2″
Silver InnerspringCharcoal Coast Pillow Top4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
6.5 (Firm)
15 1/2″Pocketed Coils (1,000)Memory Foam
Gel Memory Foam
Polyfoam
Not Disclosed
Charcoal Coast4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
7.5 (Extra Firm)
13″ to 13 1/2″
Open Seas Pillow Top4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
14″
Open Seas4 (Plush)
5 (Luxury Firm)
7.5 (Extra Firm)
11″ to 12″

 

Tidewater4 (Plush)11 1/2″

Firmness is rated on a scale of 1 to 10. For more information on how firmness is calculated, please visit our Mattress Firmness page.

 

Sleep Trial and Warranty Information

Trial Period and Guarantee: Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are available through third-party retailers. For this reason, customers should defer to the sleep trial and return policy of the brick-and-mortar location where they purchase their mattress.

Warranty: Simmons Bedding Company offers a 10-year limited warranty for all currently manufactured mattresses.

  1. Warranty coverage begins on the date of original purchase. Coverage will be nonprorated for the entire warranty period.
  2. This warranty protects against defective mattresses. Customers with defective models should contact the original mattress seller; if this business has closed or moved since the mattress was purchased, they should then contact Simmons Bedding Company. Owners will be asked to provide original proof of purchase, as well as information on the law label.
  3. Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are designed for use with certain types of foundational support systems. According to the company, this is defined as any foundation that ‘provides rigid center support as well as support for the head, foot, and sides’. For Queen/King/California King mattresses, foundations with no metal center support must have at least five hardwood or metal slats, with legs attached to the three center slats. Failure to utilize a proper support system will void the warranty.
  4. The warranty is contingent on proper mattress care. Dry cleaning services are required for the cover, and owners should refrain from using cleaning fluids or fabric applications of any kind. As a safety precaution, heating pads or electric blankets should never be used on memory foam.
  5. With the exception of warranty-holders in California, mattress owners will be responsible for all costs associated with shipping, handling, and inspecting potentially defective mattresses.
  6. The replacement of a defective mattress will not extend the warranty coverage period, nor will it result in the creation of a new warranty.
  7. The warranty will cover the following mattress defects:
    • Visible indentations or sagging in the mattress surface that measure one and a half inches (1 1/2″) or deeper for innersprings, or three-quarters of an inch (3/4″) or deeper for hybrid models.
  8. The warranty will not cover the following
    • Indentations or sagging that measure less than one and a half inches (1 1/2″) for innersprings, or three-quarters of an inch (3/4″) for hybrid models. This is considered standard wear and tear.
    • Repair or replacement requests that occur due to changes in the owner’s comfort preferences.
    • Burns, cuts, tears, and other types of damage that occur due to owner misuse, improper cleaning, and/or inadequate foundational support.
    • Mattresses stained with blood, bodily fluids, or other liquids; these mattresses are considered unsanitary.
  9. Warranty coverage is exclusively extended to original owners that have purchased their mattress directly from an authorized Simmons Beautyrest retailer. Anyone who buys or acquires the mattress from the original owner or an unauthorized dealer will not be eligible for warranty protection. In addition, a warranty will not be granted to those who purchase floor models or used mattresses.  
 

Simmons Beautyrest Mattress Sleep Ratings

CategoryCriteriaInnerspring RatingHybrid RatingWhat Simmons Beautyrest Users Say
Customer SatisfactionBased on data collection, this is an overall customer sentiment regarding Simmons Beautyrest mattresses.67 (Platinum)
64 (Black)
62 (Silver)

 

64 (Silver)
62 (Platinum)

 

Innersprings in the Platinum Collection have earned a slightly above-average rating compared to other innersprings, while the remaining Simmons Beautyrest mattresses have earned below-average customer scores.
Durability The average mattress will perform for approximately seven years before it needs to be replaced.FairFairLongevity is the chief complaint among Simmons Beautyrest owners, with many claiming their mattresses show indentations and/or sagging after four years or less.
Motion IsolationInnerspring and hybrid mattresses are designed with responsive sleep surfaces, and generally do not isolate motion as much as all-foam models.GoodGoodCompared to other innersprings and hybrids, Simmons Beautyrest mattresses minimize and isolate motion to a greater extent; this is due in part to the use of memory foam in the comfort layer in most models.
Sex Bouncier, more responsive beds such as innersprings and hybrids tend to be most enjoyable for sex.Very GoodVery GoodSimmons Beautyrest hybrids and innersprings are highly responsive, and owners report they are suitable for sex as a result.
ConformingInnerspring and hybrid mattresses generally do not conform very closely or provide much pressure relief compared to memory foam or latex models. FairGoodCustomer feedback indicates that Simmons Beautyrest hybrids conform more closely than other similar models, resulting in above-average pressure relief. The company’s innersprings do not conform as much.
Temperature NeutralityInnersprings and hybrids retain less body heat than other mattress types, and usually ‘sleep cooler’ as a result.FairFairSimmons Beautyrest owners claim their innersprings/hybrids tend to sleep hot, which is most likely due to the use of memory foam in their comfort layers.
Off-gassingSome mattresses emit particles when they are unpackaged, accompanied by unpleasant ‘off-gassing’ smells that can last for days.FairFairMemory foam is one of the biggest culprits for off-gassing, and Simmons Beautyrest owners report these mattresses produce more odor than other innersprings and hybrids.
Edge SupportInnerspring and hybrid mattresses typically offer strong edge support and are less likely to sink prematurely where people sit.Very GoodVery GoodInnersprings and hybrids from Simmons Beautyrest (particularly those with foam-encased support cores) offer robust edge support.
NoiseAll-foam mattresses are typically silent, but hybrids and innersprings may produce some noise due to their metallic components.GoodGoodDespite the presence of metallic coils, innersprings and hybrids from Simmons Beautyrest produce minimal noise.
Ease of Moving and RotatingMost mattresses are relatively heavy, but some can be more unwieldy than others.FairFairInnersprings and hybrids tend to be the heaviest mattresses available, and Simmons Beautyrest models are no exception.
 

Simmons Beautyrest Customer Satisfaction Rating Comparison

What Type of Sleeper Is Best Suited for a Simmons Beautyrest Mattress?

Based on our customer feedback, Simmons Beautyrest mattresses received the following grades among sleepers of different weights and preferred sleep positions. Please note that these ratings are subjective, and that everyone has varying experiences on different mattresses. Sleeper comfort and spinal support are the most important factors when it comes to selecting a mattress.

Mattress CollectionSleep PositionLightweight Sleeper Rating (Less than 130 lbs)Average Weight Sleeper Rating (130 to 230 lbs)Heavyweight Sleeper Rating (More than 230 lbs)
Black SideFairGoodGood
BackFairFairGood
StomachFairGoodGood
Platinum (Innerspring)SideGoodGoodFair
BackGoodFairFair
StomachFairFairGood
Platinum (Hybrid)SideFairFairGood
BackFairFairGood
StomachFairGoodGood
Silver (Innerspring)SideGoodGoodFair
BackGoodGoodFair
StomachGoodFairFair
Silver (Hybrid)SideFairFairGood
BackFairFairGood
StomachFairGoodGood

For more information on sleeping positions please see our guides for side, back, stomach and combination sleepers.

 

Simmons Bedding Co. Company Information

Customer Service: Customer service experiences with Simmons Bedding Company vary due to third-party retailers. We recommend researching the background and reputation of mattress sellers in your area before making a final purchase.
BBB rating: B
Company History: Simmons Bedding Company was founded in 1870. In 2012, the company (along with Serta) was acquired by Advent International.
Physical Stores: Simmons Bedding Company does not operate any brick-and-mortar showrooms, but the company’s mattresses are available at retail locations across the country
Corporate Address:
5100 W. W.T. Harris Boulevard # R
Charlotte, NC 28269-2157
Phone Number: 1-770-512-7700 (for general questions) and 1-877-399-9397 (for warranty-related inquiries)
Contact Email: Online form
Company Website: http://www.beautyrest.com/
Facebook
Instagram
Twitter

 

Complaints

General customer complaints about Simmons Beautyrest mattresses include:

  • Performance issues such as below-average durability, poor motion isolation, and high body heat retention.
  • An above-average price-point for most mattress models.
  • Limited information available about mattress specifications and components.
 
Popular Reads
Stages of Sleep and Sleep Cycles

Usually sleepers pass through five stages: 1, 2, 3, 4 ...

Mattress Reviews and Comparisons 2018 – Complete Mattress Database

The research team at Tuck has put together the most ...

Parent’s Guide to Healthy Sleep

Every child needs good sleep for healthy development, growth, and ...