The Best Cotton Sheets – 2019 Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

OUR REVIEW PROCESS | DISCLOSURE

 

Tuck’s mattress and bedding recommendations are based on more than 300,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the sleep product you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

Shopping for cotton bed sheets can be confusing. There are tons of materials to choose from, as well as weaves, features, and thread count to consider. This guide recommends top cotton bed sheets and explains the benefits of sleeping on cotton, how to sort through the options, and factors to consider for finding the best sheets for a good night’s sleep.

We give you all the information you need to make an informed buying decision when shopping for the best cotton sheets. A good night’s sleep can make everything better, and your sheets are an important part of your sleep experience. Below you’ll find our top picks for best cotton sheets sold today. Our choices are based on verified customer and owner experiences, as well as intensive product research and analysis.

Best Cotton Sheets of 2019

Editor’s Pick – Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set

Best Price – California Design Den Combed-Cotton Sheets

Best Luxury – Boll & Branch Solid Hemmed Sheet Set

Best Pima Cotton – Gryphon Comfort Washed Sheets

Best Egyptian Cotton – Pure Parima Yalda Sheet Set

Best Cooling – Parachute Percale

How We Decided

 

46 cotton sheet sets considered –– 36 hours of research –– 4 experts consulted

Best Cotton Bed Sheets – Tuck's Top 6 Picks

Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheets – Editor's Pick

Highlights
  • Blended Egyptian/Indian cotton
  • 480 thread count
  • Includes 1 flat sheet, 1 fitted sheet and 2 pillowcases
  • 15″ pocket depth
  • Free exchanges and replacements

Cotton fabric comes in a wide range of variations, from inexpensive to high-end, but high-quality sheet sets at reasonable price-points are widely available. Our Editor’s Pick, the Luxe Core Sheet Set from Brooklinen, is a prime example. The sheets and pillowcases in this collection are made from a blend of Egyptian and Indian cotton, resulting in a soft and breathable material that sleeps very cool. The cotton is also fairly durable, due to its impressive 480 thread-count (much higher than most other sets at this price), and the fabric won’t pill as easily.

Brooklinen sells the Luxe Core Sheet Set in six sizes ranging from Twin to California King. Customers may also choose from 11 different colors and patterns. The pillowcases have envelope enclosures, which contain pillow contents fairly well and result in less clumping than cases with side openings. The sheets and pillowcases are also easy to clean, and can be washed and dried in machines. Brooklinen backs the Luxe Core Sheet Set with a full satisfaction guarantee, including free exchanges and replacements.

California Design Den Combed-Cotton Sheets – Best Price

Highlights
  • 100% long staple cotton
  • 400 thread-count
  • Includes 1 flat sheet, 1 fitted sheet and 2 pillowcases
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • Full satisfaction guarantee

Every shopper has an optimal price range for their new sheet set, but most consider any collection that costs less than $100 to be fairly reasonable. Our Best Price pick, the Combed-Cotton Sheet Set from California Design Den, is exceptionally low-priced at less than $50 in all seven sizes. The sheets and pillowcases are made from long staple combed-cotton, an exceptionally soft and light material that provides excellent breathability for hot sleepers. The materials also have a 400 thread-count, which is somewhat rare at this price-point.

The fitted sheet in the Combed-Cotton Sheet Set has a pocket depth of 18″, which is suitable for the vast majority of mattresses sold today. California Design Den offers 23 different solid colors and pattern options, all of which have an attractive sateen finish. The materials in this set are OEKO-TEX 100 certified, which indicates no chemicals are used during production. California Design Den offers a full satisfaction guarantee for all orders.

Boll & Branch Solid Hemmed Sheet Set – Best Luxury

Highlights
  • Blended Indian/Portuguese organic cotton
  • 300 thread count
  • Includes 1 flat sheet, 1 fitted sheet and 1-2 pillowcases
  • 17″ pocket depth
  • 100-night sleep trial

Our Best Luxury pick is the Solid Hemmed Sheet Set from Boll & Branch. These sheets and pillowcases are crafted from a sumptuous blend of Indian and Portuguese organic-cotton. The material has a silky-soft feet and provides exceptional cooling during hotter times of the year. A 300 thread-count ensures a good balance of softness and durability.

Two pillowcases, a flat sheet, and a fitted sheet are included in sets that are Full-size or larger. The fitted sheet in all sizes offers a pocket depth of 17″, allowing it to be used with most mattresses made today (including high-profile hybrids and innersprings). Eight different sizes – including three King options – and seven solid color options are available. Boll & Branch offers a 100-night sleep trial with the Solid Hemmed Sheet Set.

Gryphon Comfort Washed Sheet Set – Best Pima Cotton

Highlights
  • 100% Supima cotton
  • 300 thread count
  • Includes 1 flat sheet, 1 fitted sheet and 2 pillowcases
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • 100-night return period

Most cotton sheet sets are reasonably soft, but our standout choice for this category is the Comfort Washed Sheet Set from Gryphon. The sheets and pillowcases are made from Supima cotton, a trademarked, U.S.-grown variety of extra-long staple Pima cotton. Pima is renowned for its silky texture and natural cooling properties. The fabric also becomes softer with each successive wash, but pilling potential is minimal and all components should withstand early wear and tear. The cotton is also OEKO-TEX certified, which ensures chemical agents and treatments are never used during manufacturing.

Compared to other Supima cotton sheet sets, the Gryphon Comfort Washed collection is fairly low-priced; all sizes are currently available for less than $170. Each set includes a flat sheet, fitted sheet, and two pillowcases. Five solid colors available. The fitted sheet’s pocket depth of 18″ makes it suitable for most mattresses made today. Gryphon offers a 100-night return period with the Comfort Washed Sheet Set.

Pure Parima Yalda Sheet Set – Best Egyptian Cotton

Highlights
  • Cotton Egypt Association certified 100% Egyptian cotton
  • 400 thread count
  • Includes 1 flat sheet, 1 fitted sheet and 1-2 pillowcases
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • 100-night sleep trial

Many consider Egyptian cotton to be the most luxurious bedding material available. Like Supima cotton, Egyptian cotton is an extra-long staple variety. Authentic Egyptian cotton – produced exclusively from fibers grown in Egypt – is a rare and fairly expensive commodity; many brands sell blended Egyptian cotton at a lower price-point. Our pick for Best Egyptian Cotton is the Pure Parima Yalda Sheet Set. These sheets and pillowcases are made of 100% Giza ELS cotton; the brand has earned a certification from the Cotton Egypt Association, which is considered the foremost authority for certifying this material.

The Yalda Sheet Set consists of a flat sheet, fitted sheet, and two pillowcases in sizes Full and larger. Each component is highly breathable, making the set optimal for hot sleepers. The ELS cotton fibers are also very resilient; as a result, the sheets and pillowcases have longer-than-average expected lifespans and won’t deteriorate due to machine washing. Pure Parima offers a 100-night sleep trial for the Yalda Sheet Set, along with full product refunds on all returns.

Parachute Percale Sheet Set – Best Cooling

Highlights
  • OEKO-TEX 100 certified
  • 400 thread count
  • Includes 1 fitted sheet and 2 pillowcases
  • 16″ pocket depth
  • 90-night sleep trial

Our pick for Best Cooling goes to the Percale Sheet Set from Parachute. The sheets and pillowcases in this collection are made from 400TC blended Egyptian cotton, a material that closely mirrors the silky-soft texture and natural breathability of authentic Egyptian cotton. The percale weave leaves each component with a crisp feel that won’t lessen with washing. Additionally, Parachute’s bedding products are ethically and sustainably sourced.

Each Percale Sheet Set includes a fitted sheet with a pocket depth of 16″, along with two pillowcases. A top sheet is available for an additional $60 to $90, depending on the set size. Customers may also choose from seven different color options. Parachute offers free shipping to customers in all 50 states, and the Percale Sheet Set is backed by a 90-night sleep trial.

Cotton Sheets Buying Guide

Bed sheets are a big part of the quality of your sleep. The more comfortable your sheets, the better you should sleep, and cotton is a top choice. Most people focus on thread count and color rather than considering weave, weight, and other important considerations.

This guide will help you understand why cotton is an excellent sheet material, the weaves to choose from, types of cotton, thread count, and other considerations to ensure you get the best sheets for your ultimate sleep experience.

Why Cotton?

For cool and soft sheets, nothing outperforms all-natural cotton. Cotton is breathable, wicks moisture, and resists stains. Cotton releases stains easily when wet, so it’s durable and wears well. The preferable type of cotton is long-staple (which means it has long fibers).

Long fibers in the weave of the cotton sheet result in discernibly better softness compared to other materials and other types of cotton. Long-staple cotton also resists pilling and won’t attract lint. Cotton outperforms most other sheet materials.

Choosing cotton sheets means you’ll notice:

  • Cooler sleep – Cotton is a naturally breathable fabric, so air circulates better around your body.
  • Drier sleep – Cotton is a thirsty fabric, so it wicks moisture away from your body.
  • Comfortable sleep – Cotton drapes softly around your body nesting you in comfort for better sleep.

If you prefer an all-natural product over synthetics, that’s another reason to choose cotton. Cotton bedsheets come in an array of eco-friendly options. Look for a 100% cotton label to know that you’re not getting a blend if you want an all-cotton sleep experience.

For those that want a purer experience, search for organic cotton. This is cotton that was grown without chemical pesticides and had no harsh processing after harvest. You can also look for sheets that use natural or low-impact dyes.

Pros of Cotton Sheets

  • Cotton sheets come in a wide range of styles, weaves, and cotton varieties. Whether they want silky-smooth sateen or crisp Egyptian Cotton percale sheets, most people can find a price range and style they love.
  • All cotton sheets are breathable, keeping you cool in the summer and warm in the winter. Their breathability means you can avoid feelings of dampness or clamminess when you climb into bed after a bath.
  • Cotton naturally wicks away moisture off your skin. Keeping you dry doesn’t just make you sleep better, it also keeps your sheets cleaner.
  • Natural fibers like cotton are often recommended to people with allergies or sensitive skin. While organic and all-natural cotton sheets are the most effective, even ordinary cotton sheets can be less irritating than synthetic materials.
  • As cotton ages, it becomes softer and more comfortable. Synthetic materials, on the other hand, tend to become stiff, “crunchy”, and uncomfortable with age.
  • If buying organic products is important to you, choosing cotton offers you that opportunity. While there are other natural fibers on the market, such as bamboo and silk, cotton is the most popular and widely available.

Cons of Cotton Sheets

  • Cotton wrinkles more than synthetic fabrics, and more than some other natural fibers. Wrinkles can be minimized by ironing sheets after washing, but most weaves will still show creases the next day.
  • Though cotton ages well, it has a shorter lifespan than synthetic materials. More expensive cotton sheets and those with higher thread counts tend to last longer than budget options.
  • Cotton sheets can be expensive, particularly the most comfortable varieties. If you have a smaller budget, it can be easier to find comfortable synthetic sheets rather than comfortable cotton sheets.
  • Because it is a natural fiber, cotton has a tendency to shrink more than man-made fabrics. To avoid shrinking, wash your sheets on a warm cycle and hang to dry.

Different Types and Weaves

Types of Cotton

Egyptian Cotton – Egyptian cotton grows only in specific regions and is hand-picked to keep the cotton fibers straight and clean. This variety is known for having excellent long-staple fibers and creates silky, durable sheets.

Pima Cotton – Pima cotton is an extra-long staple (long fiber) cotton that makes strong and soft sheets. Considered second only to Egyptian cotton, Pima may be trademarked as Supima cotton, indicating it has been grown in the U.S.

Regular Cotton – Several varieties, including American upland cotton, are considered “regular” cotton. These plants produce cotton with shorter fibers and less durability than Egyptian and pima cotton. Sheets made from ordinary cotton can be coarser as well, but are often much less expensive.

Weaves

Percale

These sheets are woven vertically and horizontally one thread at a time. They feel the same on both sides and because of the tight weave, are very smooth. To be authentic percale, thread count must be 180 or higher.

Because of their tight, even weave, percale sheets have a crisp, light texture that is sometimes compared to a dress shirt. Their breathability makes them an excellent choice for anyone who sleeps hot or wants cooler sheets for the warmer months.

Some percale sheet owners iron them to emphasize their crispness and avoid wrinkles. This makes them feel even more luxurious but isn’t necessary for a good night’s sleep. Overall, percale sheets are durable, comfortable, and light.

Sateen

These sheets are woven in a long lateral pattern and are chemically treated in a process called mercerization that soaks the cotton fabric strands in lye then an acid wash. The process makes it satiny, receptive to dye, and with a slight sheen.

Sateen’s heavier weight makes it warm and comfortable for cold weather or people who enjoy warmer sheets. Since the weave on sateen sheets exposes more of the thread, these sheets also have a silkier and less crisp feel than percale.

Caring for sateen is also easier. Because sateen sheets are naturally wrinkle-resistant, they require very little ironing. However, they can be less durable than percale and may lose their sheen over time.

Jersey

Jersey cotton isn’t woven but instead is knitted from one long continuous strand. It’s ultra-soft and drapes like t-shirt material, with little to no stiffness or crispness.

The least durable of common sheet weaves (or knits), jersey sheets are prone to pilling and holes. These downsides are tolerated by those who prize jersey’s softness and comfort, and these sheets are a good choice for anyone with ultra-sensitive skin.

Fit, Color and Pattern

Most sheets come in single, full, queen and king size. If you need a California King or Twin XL, check the options to ensure the brand offers what you need. If you have a very tall or shallow mattress, you’ll want to pay close attention to the depth of the fitted sheet pocket. Measure your mattress height as some brands come with deep and some with extra deep pockets while others aren’t as roomy.

When looking at the aesthetics of cotton sheets, consider going subtle with color. First, brightly colored sheets can be a visual distraction. Second, if you want to avoid chemicals, natural-colored sheets will have fewer dyes and processing.

Patterns are nice, but you want to coordinate with your comforter and consider what happens if you change your duvet. A neutral palette on walls, bedding and accessories is soothing and can help you get the best night’s rest in your sleep sanctuary.

Finding the Right Thread Count

What is thread count?

You calculate thread count by looking at a 1” square section of the sheet fabric. You count the number of yarn strands (threads) going lengthwise and crosswise. If there are 200 threads in one direction and 200 in the other, you add them to get a 400-thread count sheet.

Things get technical when you look at multi-ply yarn. Some yarn is single ply meaning it is one solid strand. That keeps the math simple. But if the yarn has several strands woven together to form a single strand, the manufacturer might count that as multiple threads.

400-thread count sheets made with 2-ply yarn might be marketed as 800-thread count. Be sure to look at the thread strands to accurately assess the true thread count of a cotton sheet brand you’re considering.

Why thread count isn’t everything

Thread count is important but shouldn’t be the sole determiner of your purchase decision. First, be sure that the thread count is accurate. One way to avoid the marketing hype is to look at single ply sheets, so there’s no opportunity for misleading math.

Some manufacturers use filler yarn to boost thread count artificially. Be sure to check the manufacturer specifications and reviews. You also don’t want an excessively high thread count because tighter weave can lead to material breakage and sheets that aren’t durable.

What is the ideal thread count?

Ideal thread count varies by sheet material. Here’s a look at the optimal range for each fabric:

Fabric Ideal thread count
Egyptian Cotton 300-400 count
Pima Cotton 200-400 count
Percale 250-300 count
Sateen 300-600 count
Jersey 10+ ounces per yard (Rated by weight, not thread count)
Bamboo 300 or higher count
Linen 100-200 count

Cotton Sheet Care and Maintenance

As a natural fiber, cotton is easy to care for. However, following these guidelines will help you keep your cotton sheets looking and feeling their best.

  • Sheets should be washed every week or every other week. Even if your bedding looks and feels clean, a build-up of sweat, skin cells, and skin oils can cause irritation and attract dust mites. Build-up can also cause cotton to break down more quickly.
  • The fewer laundry products you use, the longer your sheets will last. While dryer sheets and fabric softeners might make your sheets feel or smell good in the short-term, over time they can leave residue which breaks down cotton and attracts dirt. Similarly, using bleach should be a last resort, as regular bleaching can cause fiber damage. Instead, pre-treat stains with an enzyme solution and look for a gentle, ph-balanced detergent.
  • Treat your sheets gently when washing them. Natural fibers like cotton can tolerate higher heat than synthetics, but that doesn’t mean you should wash them on an extra-hot cycle. Wash your sheets alone on a warm cycle to avoid damage and pilling.
  • Hang your sheets to dry if possible. Sunlight disinfects, lightens stains, and keeps white sheets looking pristine. If using a dryer, look for a no-heat or low-heat cycle. Hot air not only weakens cotton fibers but can also change the texture of your sheets.

What Else Should You Consider When Buying Cotton Sheets?

Choice of cotton bed sheets is subjective. In the end, what matters is how the sheets feel against your skin and how they perform for your unique circumstances. Be sure the size is a match, and the pocket is deep enough to fit your bed. If you sleep hot or cold, look for cotton sheets designed to warm or cool.

Here are some other factors to consider:

Set or Individual Pieces?

The typical bed sheet set is a fitted sheet, top sheet, and 1-2 pillowcases. If you don’t want a top sheet or want more pillowcases, some brands let you customize your set.

Organic Cotton

Natural cotton sheets are those made with 100% raw ingredients found in nature, meaning there are no synthetics blended with it. Organic cotton goes a step further and is grown and processed without pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, or chemicals. It is also harvested by hand so that the raw cotton can be hand-cleaned with soap rather than a chemical solution.

Organic cotton sheets are almost always more expensive than the conventional variety. However, choosing organic might be worthwhile if you are concerned about the environmental impact of conventional cotton. It is also a good option for people who have had allergic reactions to sheets in the past.

Return Policy

If you’re not sure what cotton sheets are best for you, buying from a manufacturer that offers a sleep trial or satisfaction-guaranteed return policy may be the way to go.

Additional Tuck Resources

Cotton is only one of the many materials used in sheets. Visit the links below to learn more about different types of sheets, as well as the best in each category: