Best Fiber Mattress Toppers – Top Picks and Buyer’s Guide

Our Review Process

 

Tuck’s mattress and sleep product recommendations are based on more than 300,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a sleep product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the product you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

Mattress toppers are individual layers of bedding material that are placed on sleep surfaces to adjust the firmness and provide extra cushioning. Most toppers are one to four inches thick, and may rest freely on the bedding surface, be placed beneath a topsheet, or be attached to the mattress corners using elastic loops. Toppers can benefit sleepers who find their current mattress too soft or thick, as well as those who are dissatisfied with the overall thickness of their bed.

Today’s toppers are made from a wide range of materials. Some are filled with down alternative fibers made of polyester puffballs that mimic the lightness and softness of authentic down. Down alternative fiber toppers have certain advantages over authentic down models; they are hypoallergenic, for one, and won’t trigger any symptoms for sleepers who are allergic to down. They also tend to cost much less, despite comparable lifespans.

Read on to learn more about toppers filled with down alternative fibers, as well as shopping tips for first-time buyers. Below you’ll find our picks for the best fiber toppers sold today. Our choices are based on verified customer and owner experiences, as well as intensive product research and analysis.

Best Fiber Mattress Toppers

Editor’s Pick – Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper

Runner-Up Pick – Linens & Hutch Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper

Best Cooling Fiber Topper – Leisure Town Overfilled Mattress Topper

Best Plush Fiber Topper – Naluka Mattress Topper

How We Decided

 

37 fiber mattress toppers considered –– 65 hours of research –– 4 sleep experts consulted

Best Fiber Mattress Toppers – Tuck's Top 4 Picks

Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper – Editor's Pick

Highlights
  • Quilted cotton cover
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • Comfortable and temperature-neutral
  • 60-night trial and 3-year warranty

Our Editor’s Pick is the Down Alternative Mattress Topper from Parachute, which exemplifies the softness, comfort, and support of the best fiber toppers available. This topper is constructed with a breathable sateen cotton cover; the baffled design allows the topper to maintain a full shape, and minimal fluffing is required. The quilted pockets also allow air to circulate, which cools off the topper and keeps it temperature-neutral for sleeping, and the double-stitched construction prevents the down alternative fibers from escaping.

The pocket depth for this topper is 18″, meaning it will comfortable fit any mattress that is 18″ thick or less; this range represents the vast majority of mattresses sold today. The topper is also machine washable, making it easy to clean and keep hygienic. The Down Alternative Mattress Topper is backed by a 60-night sleep trial and three-year warranty, both of which are longer than average. Parachute offers free shipping and returns, as well.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy)
  • Hot sleepers
  • Couples

Linens & Hutch Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper – Runner-Up Pick

Highlights
  • Polyester cover
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • Great fill distribution and shape retention
  • 60-night trial

Our Runner-Up Pick, the Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper from Linens & Hutch, is packed with soft down alternative fill for an exceptionally soft, body-cushioning feel. It is designed with a quilted polyester cover that provides even fill distribution throughout. This helps the topper maintain a full shape with minimal fluffing. The baffles also promote great air circulation to keep the topper cool and comfortable for most. The pocket depth is 18″, making it suitable for most mattresses sold today, and the elastic edges are exceptionally durable.

This topper is available in Queen, King, and California King sizes, and is a great choice for couples. It is also machine washable. The Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper has an above-average price-point compared to other fiber toppers, making it a good pick for shoppers with bigger budgets. It is backed by a 60-night sleep trial.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy)
  • Hot sleepers
  • Couples

Leisure Town Overfilled Mattress Topper – Best Cooling Fiber Topper

Highlights
  • Combed cotton cover
  • 21″ pocket depth
  • Breathable and very cool
  • 1-year warranty

While most fiber toppers sleep relatively cool, the Leisure Town Overfilled Mattress Topper is a standout for temperature neutrality. This is due in part to its breathable combed-cotton cover, which is fashioned with HNN cooling technology that resists body heat and won’t make sleepers sweat. The diamond-quilted baffles promote good air flow, as well. Additionally, the cover is water-resistant; fluid will not seep into the mattress if it measure less than 200 milliliters.

Size selection is another strength of the Leisure Town Overfilled Mattress Topper. It is available in seven sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King, as well as the hard-to-find Olympic Queen size. It also has a pocket depth of 21″, meaning it will fit over virtually every mattress model made today. This topper is machine washable, and it is backed by a one-year warranty. Its price-point is below-average, as well.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy)
  • Couples
  • Value seekers

Naluka Mattress Topper – Best Plush Fiber Topper

Highlights
  • Polyester cover
  • 18″ pocket depth
  • Exceptionally soft and body-cushioning
  • Customer satisfaction guarantee

Fiber toppers are known for their softness, but the Naluka Mattress Topper is plush and light even by down alternative standards. It is overfilled to create a plush, pillow-top surface that cradles the sleeper’s body and allows them to sink a bit without sagging into the topper. The topper is housed within a breathable, quilted polyester cover that ensures good fill distribution and excellent shape retention; durable double-stitching also prevents fill from escaping over time.

The Naluka Mattress Topper also offers great stability, thanks to hyper-elastic edges that will fit mattresses up to 18″ thick. It can be washed and tumble dried in a machine for added convenience. The topper has a below-average price-point, making it a high-value pick, but its expected lifespan is on par with other, higher-priced models. The Naluka Mattress Topper is backed by a full customer satisfaction guarantee, as well.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy)
  • Hot sleepers
  • Value seekers

Best Fiber Mattress Toppers Buyer's Guide

A ‘topper’ refers to any individual cushioning layer that can be placed on top of a mattress or other sleep surface for additional softness, comfort and — in some cases — improved support. Some toppers fit beneath top sheets, while others lie freely on the comfort layer of the mattress. Toppers are available to accommodate most standard mattress sizes; the topper is slightly smaller than the mattress, allowing it to fit more easily beneath the sheet.

A ‘fiber topper’, also known as a ‘fiberbed,’ is typically constructed with polyester or down alternative puff fiber fill encased in a fabric or microfiber cover. Cover composition for fiber toppers varies by model, but most are made from cotton, polyester, and/or rayon. Some fiberbed covers are made from organic cotton, as well; these models tend to have higher price-points.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Fiber Toppers?

Benefits of using a fiber topper of fiberbed include the following:

  • Low Cost: Fiberbeds are among the least expensive mattress toppers sold today, with an average price-point of $60 to $100, and they tend to provide more ‘bang for your buck’ than other topper types.
  • Pain and Pressure Relief: Fiberbeds can improve the comfort and softness of most sleep surfaces, which may help reduce pain and alleviate pressure points in the neck, shoulders, lumbar region, and other potentially sensitive areas of the body.
  • Lightweight: Most fiber toppers weigh 10 pounds or less, making them relatively easy to adjust and maneuver during the night compared to other toppers.
  • Ease of Movement: Fiber beds do not sink deeply or conform closely, which provides a low-resistance sleep surface.
  • Good for Sex: Fiberbeds are fairly responsive and do not restrict movement to a significant extent, making them highly suitable for sex.
  • No Odor: Compared to other topper types, such as memory foam or wool, fiber toppers emit minimal odor when they are unpackaged and owners report little to no long-lasting smells.

Notable drawbacks of using a fiber topper are as follows:

  • Short Lifespan: Fiberbeds often become flat or misshapen after limited use, which can reduce their ability to provide optimal comfort and softness.
  • Noise Potential: Many fiberbeds produce sounds when they are bearing weight, which may lead to sleep disruptions for people who awaken easily due to noise.
  • Poor Motion Isolation: Compared to other topper options (such as memory foam and latex models), fiberbeds do not absorb or isolate motion to a significant extent. This may be problematic for couples who share a mattress.
  • Sleeping Hot: Temperature neutrality in fiberbeds often varies by specific materials used, but generally speaking these toppers sleep somewhat hot.
  • High Maintenance: Fiberbeds require constant shaking and fluffing in order to maintain optimal loft and shape. Additionally, washing them in machines can cause early deterioration; dry cleaning is recommended instead.
  • Limited Thickness: Most fiberbeds measure two inches thick or less, which may be too limiting for sleepers who prefer thicker, fuller toppers.

Who Should Use a Fiber Topper?

A fiberbed is typically considered most suitable for the following groups:

  • People who experience pain and pressure in the neck, shoulders, lower back, and/or hips. Although fiberbeds do not provide as much pain and pressure relief as other topper options, a significant percentage of owners claim they experience less discomfort after using them.
  • People who are sensitive to smell. Fiberbeds emit little to no off-gassing, and are not associated with unpleasant or long-lasting odors.
  • People who have a hard time lifting heavy objects. Fiberbeds are light compared to other topper options, with an average weight of five to 10 pounds.
  • Topper shoppers on a budget. Fiberbeds are second only to convoluted polyfoam toppers in terms of low average price-point among all topper types.

On the other hand, a fiberbed may not be suitable for the following groups:

  • People who tend to sleep hot. Fiber toppers may retain and trap body heat, causing sleepers to become too hot or warm during the night.
  • People who awaken easily due to noise or motion. Fiberbeds can be somewhat noisy, and they do not isolate motion as effectively as other toppers.
  • People who prefer a closely conforming topper. While fiberbeds can alleviate pain and pressure, they do not provide the same close, contoured fit as other topper types, such as memory foam or latex.
  • People who prefer thick toppers. Most fiberbeds sold today measure two inches thick or less, making them relatively thin.

How Much Does a Fiber Topper Cost?

The average fiberbed costs between $60 and $100. Comparatively, convoluted polyfoam toppers typically cost between $10 and $30, while all other topper types (including memory foam, latex, and wool) have higher average price-points. However, fiber toppers with organic materials may cost more. The graph below compares average price-points for the six most common topper types.

Fiber Topper Price Comparison

Fiber Topper Customer Ratings

Criteria Fiber Topper Rating Explanation
Thickness Selection Poor to Fair Fiberbeds generally measure two inches thick or less, which may not be sufficient for some sleepers. Thicker models are available, but the price-points tend to be higher.
Durability Poor to Fair According to owners, fiber toppers tend to become flat or misshapen after one to two years of use. This poor shape retention can affect the topper’s ability to improve mattress comfort.
Support Fair to Good Fiberbeds may be able to improve mattress support to some extent, but other topper types — notably foam and latex — perform better in this category.
Conforming Poor to Fair Fiberbeds provide little to no conforming, and may not be suitable for sleepers that enjoy the contoured feel of latex or memory foam.
Pain/Pressure Relief Good to Very Good Despite their minimal conforming abilities, fiberbeds are soft enough to alleviate pain and pressure for most sleepers.
Motion Isolation Poor to Fair Fiberbeds cannot isolate motion to the same extent as foam or latex toppers. For this reason, they may lead to sleep disruptions for people who share beds when one person gets in/out of bed ot shifts positions.
Noise Fair to Good Fiberbeds may produce rustling sounds, which can be an issue for people who awaken easily. Other topper types — such as wool, memory foam, and latex — are virtually silent.
Temperature Neutrality Fair to Good Fiberbeds may retain body heat and sleep hot, although these complaints are not as common for models with covers made from natural fibers like cotton.
Odor Very Good to Excellent Fiberbeds produce very little odor (if any at all), making them a good alternative to relatively smelly toppers (such as foam, wool, and feather models).
Sex Good to Very Good Fiberbeds are fairly responsive and do not restrict movement, making them better for sex than other topper options.
Ease of Moving Good to Very Good With an average weight of five to 10 pounds, fiberbeds are much easier to move and maneuver than other topper types. Thicker models may present more difficulty.
Ease of Cleaning Poor to Fair Most fiberbeds are advertised as machine washable, but this cleaning method can lead to early deterioration; dry cleaning is generally recommended.
Maintenance Poor to Fair Fiberbeds require regular shaking and fluffing in order to maintain a full shape — and even then, they tend to become flat and compressed after limited use.
Availability Good to Very Good Fiberbeds are widely available, although thickness options are generally limited to two inches or less.
Average Price $60 to $100 Fiber toppers are among the least expensive topper options sold today. Memory foam, latex, feather, and wool toppers all have higher average price-points.

Conclusion