The Best Waterproof Mattress Pads and Protectors – 2018 Reviews and Buying Guide

Our Review Process

 

Tuck’s mattress recommendations are based on more than 5,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the mattress you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

One of the biggest threats to the lifespan of a mattress is a nasty spill or accident. The introduction of moisture to a mattress can lead to stains, mold, and other degradation that erodes the longevity of your bed. Whether you’ve just purchased a new mattress or are trying to make an older one last as long as possible, a waterproof mattress pad or protector can help prevent this kind of damage.

There are numerous waterproof products on the market and considerable diversity in the quality and cost of these products. In this guide, we’ll give an overview of the benefits of a waterproof mattress pad or protector, tips for how to choose one, and our list of the best waterproof mattress pads and protectors available to you right now.

The Best Waterproof Mattress Pads and Protectors of 2018

Editor’s Pick – Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector

Best Cooling – Bear Protector

Best for Added Comfort – Helix Mattress Protector

Best Value – SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

How We Decided
24 mattress pads and protectors considered –– 52 hours of research –– 4 sleep experts consulted

Waterproof Mattress Pads and Protectors Reviews

Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector – Editor’s Pick

Highlights
  • Food-grade polyurethane backing offers waterproofing without health risks
  • Polyester cover has phase-change material to help with temperature regulation
  • Extra-deep pockets can fit mattresses up to 18” deep
  • Sleep trial of 100 nights

Nest Bedding’s Cooling Mattress Protector delivers protection and comfort all in one. The waterproofing comes from a polyurethane backing, and the polyurethane is food-grade meaning that it won’t off-gas or emit potentially harmful chemicals.

The top layer of fabric is made with polyester that has a phase-change material. This helps dissipate heat from the body and maintain an even temperature between your body and the sleeping surface. It’s also a soft pad that won’t detract from the comfort of your bed, and since it’s virtually noiseless, it won’t disrupt you while sleeping.

The protector covers 5 sides of the bed and has deep pockets that allow it to fit even very tall beds (18”). It can be machine washed and dried and comes with a test-out period of 100 nights during which you can return it if you aren’t satisfied.

Bear Protector – Best Cooling

Highlights
  • Fully waterproof and protective against spills
  • HeiQ Adaptive Fabric keeps you cool and dry
  • Compatible with mattresses that have Celliant technology
  • Extremely quiet

The Bear Protector from the makers of the Bear Mattress is a strong pick for anyone who wants a pad that can keep their mattress safe from spills while also keeping them cool and comfortable through the night.

Using the HeiQ Adaptive Fabric, the protector holds up well against all kind of spills and is 100% waterproof. At the same time, the material is breathable and helps to wick moisture and excess heat away from your body. For people who use mattresses with Celliant technology (such as the Bear Mattress or Amerisleep mattresses), this pad is compatible and does not interrupt the infrared energy and heat transfer from that material.

With its soft surface and special non-polyurethane material, the Bear Protector stays extremely quiet even when you move on it, and it provides a defense against allergens and dust along the 5 sides of the bed that it covers. It also stretches to cover mattresses up to 20” tall.

For hot sleepers looking for robust mattress protection, this product is a top pick.

Helix Mattress Protector – Best for Added Comfort

Highlights
  • Polyurethane provides steady defense against spills
  • Stretchy polyester top layer adds softness to enhance the feel of your mattress
  • Breathable surface maintains airflow and keeps you dry
  • Fabric stays quiet even with movement

The Helix Mattress Protector from the company that makes the mattress of the same name is made from a combination of polyester and TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane). The polyester in the top layer is extra soft, so even though it is a thin layer of material, it provides an extra touch of plushness while maintaining the overall feel of your mattress. The TPU is a strong waterproofing material that will keep your mattress safe from stains and moisture.

Skirting goes around the sides to hold the pad in place, and the material is virtually noiseless, preventing the crinkly sound associated with some other mattress protectors. It can be machine washed and dried, so any spills are easy to resolve.

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector – Best Value

Highlights
  • Entry-level price point
  • Laminated polyurethane backing creates stable waterproof seal
  • Thin enough to not affect feel of the mattress
  • Track record of durability with frequent washing

Our best value pick for the top mattress pads and protectors is the SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector. Its price is less than half of other pads and protectors, but it delivers trustworthy protection for your mattress. Its construction is generally simpler than the other pads on our list: it has limited padding in its top layer, which is a cotton and polyester blend. But it still has a fortified backing made with laminated polyurethane that can give you confidence that moisture won’t leak through to your mattress.

This pad won’t disrupt the comfort provided by your mattress, and while it makes some noise when you move on it, it’s not enough noise to disrupt the majority of sleepers. The material in the pad holds up well with washing, which can be done in the washing machine. Given its price point and performance, the SafeRest Premium Mattress Pad stands out as the best bet for value.

Waterproof Mattress Pads and Protectors Buying Guide

Whether you’re currently in the marker for a waterproof mattress protector, or interested in learning why one may be a good investment, this guide will give an overview of the benefits and provide the information you need to help identify the best purchase option for your home.

Why You Want a Waterproof Mattress Protector

Your mattress is a serious investment, and a mattress pad or protector can provide some insurance for your purchase. If you take a close look at your mattress warranty, odds are it doesn’t cover damage caused by moisture or spills. As a result, a pad or protector can be a cost-effective way to protect your mattress.

This added protection can help extend the life of your mattress by lowering the risk of mold and mildew buildup caused by moisture getting into the mattress. Of course, it’s great for keeping those unwanted stains out of your mattress as well. And for people who may have issues with incontinence or children who occasionally wet the bed, a mattress protector can help there, too.

Additionally, using a waterproof pad or protector reduces the build-up of allergens and other particles in your mattress. Keep an eye out for a hypoallergenic pads if this is an important feature for you.

And finally, a waterproof pad or protector makes cleanup so much simpler. When an accident occurs, just remove the protector and any bedding and throw them in the wash. Easy!

What You Need to Know when You’re Buying a Waterproof Mattress Protector

As you compare and contrast your options, it can be useful to know about some of the factors that allow you to differentiate between the various mattress pads and protectors on the market.

Styles

There are basically 4 styles of waterproof mattress pads and protectors available.

  • Fitted sheet – These go over the top and sides of the mattress and use a fitted corner to help secure the protector in place. This works the same way as a standard fitted sheet with the main difference being that a waterproof protector has a specialized backing to protect the bed.
  • 6-sided protector – This encases all 6 sides of the mattress and is normally sealed with a zipper. This is the most complete form of protection for the mattress and may be referred to as a mattress encasement. These tend to be especially useful for people who have concerns about bed bugs or allergens.
  • Fitted pad – This is similar to the fitted sheet except that there is a thicker material on top that generally provides a softer feel than the simple fitted-sheet style protector.
  • Pad – Pads are designed to offer protection to a specific area on the bed and are often placed above the bedsheet. Unlike other options, you aren’t able to secure pads in place.

Fabrics

Fabrics used in waterproof pads and protectors can generally be classified in two categories: The top cover and the waterproof backing. Materials that are often used in the top part include:

  • Cotton – This material is generally soft and smooth and for that reason employed in a huge variety of textiles like clothes and bedding. But cotton is also absorbent, so it needs a strong waterproof backing to work well in a protector or pad.
  • Polyester – This synthetic material can be produced to have different feels, but the most common have some softness (though less than cotton) but with more breathability and less absorption.
  • Rayon – Rayon is a semi-synthetic material (made from natural materials but using various chemicals) that often has a smooth, cooling, and breathable feel.
  • Lyocell – This is a wood-pulp based textile often marketed as Tencel. It tends to have a soft feel; and though not fully waterproof, does hold up better against liquids.
  • Blends – It’s not uncommon to find blends of the above materials. Manufacturers may compose these blends to provide a specific feel or performance of the fabric.

Pads and protectors use an adhesive to apply a waterproof backing to the topmost fabric. Some of the waterproofing materials that may be used include:

  • Vinyl – Vinyl maintains a powerful waterproof seal and is highly effective as a backing in pads and protectors. However, many vinyl products contain phthalates, which raise some health concerns, especially for pregnant women and children. However, some vinyl products are sold as phthalate-free.
  • Polyurethane – This is a plastic polymer material often used for waterproofing. It can be laminated or thermally bonded to a fabric to hold it in place. Thermally-bonded polyurethane may also be referred to as TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane).

Cleaning

It’s important to know about the cleaning process for any mattress pad or protector. Most can be washed and dried in the washing machine, but it’s important to use low temperatures. This is because high temperatures can degrade the adhesives that are necessary to maintain the waterproof backing. You can also hand wash and line dry the pads and protectors. When necessary, such as in the case of spills, you easily spot clean most pads and protectors with a mild soap.

The more you wash a pad or protector, the faster it will start to break down. That said, you still want to try to have a somewhat regular schedule for washing it. You don’t want or need to wash it as often as your normal sheets, but it can be good to clean it so that there is no buildup of dust or odor.

In addition, always remember to check the manufacturer’s instructions for cleaning because there can be some variation from product to product. Following these instructions carefully can help extend the life of your purchase.

When to Replace

Mattress pads and protectors eventually wear out as the top layer and/or the waterproof backing gives out. This usually happens from washing, which causes slow degradation of these materials. Depending on how frequently you wash your pad or protector, you can expect it to last anywhere from several months to years. This can also depend on the materials and their quality since poorly produced adhesives will be more inclined to wear away rapidly. If you notice the material wearing thin or failing to protect against spills, it’s time to consider replacing your pad or protector.

What Else Should You Consider?

Now that you know the key components of a waterproof pad or protector, it’s time to review some of other considerations when looking to purchase this product.

  • Noise – Some materials used for these products can make noise when you move on top of them. This tends to be more of an issue with pads that have a more plastic-like feel. Materials like cotton and blended synthetics tend to be quieter.
  • Breathability – For people who are worried about sleeping hot, look for materials that can promote breathability, such as rayon or synthetic blends. These can help avoid heat retention in a mattress pad. Some pads may also have specific materials intended to promote cooling.
  • Comfort – The amount of thickness of the top of the pad or protector can affect how your bed will feel. If it’s a thin protector, it probably won’t affect comfort as it fits underneath your sheets. But a pad with a thicker top may be able to protect your mattress and add softness and comfort at the same time.
  • Bed bugs – If you are wanting a shield to protect your mattress from bed bugs, look for an encasement that protects all 6 sides of the mattress with a zippered closure.
  • Allergens – While most pads and protectors reduce allergen buildup, if you are highly sensitive to allergens, a full encasement is usually the most powerful product available to you.
  • Return policy – Some pads or protectors come with an in-home sleep trial, but many do not offer any kinds of returns. Check with the seller before making your purchase to find out what your rights are for making a return.
  • Warranty – Some protectors are sold with a warranty ranging from 1 to 10 years. Some warranties have so many exclusions as to make them of limited use, but it’s worth reading the fine print to see what is and is not covered.