Best Feather Pillows – Top Picks and Buyer’s Guide

Our Review Process
Tuck’s mattress and bedding recommendations are based on more than 300,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a sleep product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the product you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

Feather pillows are popular among sleepers because they sleep cool and feel exceptionally soft. Despite their name, most pillows in this category are filled with two materials: the coarse outer plumage of ducks or geese (known as ‘feathers’) and the softer inner plumage (known as ‘down’). Down is often used to pad the edges of the pillow while feathers are used in the center to provide more support and stability.

Feather pillows can beneficial for sleepers who find other pillow types to be excessively firm and hot. However, feather pillows do not provide the same levels of conforming and pressure relief as pillows made from other materials, such as memory foam or latex. Feathers may also trigger allergies in some sleepers; down alternative (a material made from polyester puffballs) might be a more suitable alternative for people with allergies.

This guide will explore the various pros and cons of feather pillows. Below you will find our picks for the best feather pillows sold today. Our choices are based on verified customer and owner experiences, as well as intensive product research and analysis.

Best Feather Pillows

Editor’s Pick – Canadian Down and Feather Co. Down Perfect Pillow

Best Value Feather Pillow – JA Comforts Goose Feather Down Pillow

Best Luxury Feather Pillow – Malouf Z TripleLayer Down Pillow

Best Feather Pillow for Side Sleepers – Three Geese White Feather Pillow

How We Decided

 

36 feather pillows considered –– 80 hours of research –– 4 sleep experts consulted

Best Feather Pillows – Tuck's Top 4 Picks

Canadian Down and Feather Co. Down Perfect Pillow – Editor's Pick

Highlights
  • Multiple firmness options
  • 5-year warranty
  • 575+ Fill Power Down
  • Supportive, multi-chambered construction
  • Sleeps exceptionally cool

A common complaint among feather pillow owners is that the surface is too soft to adequately support their head, neck, and shoulders. Our Editor’s Pick, the Down Perfect pillow from Canadian Down and Feather Co., is an exception to this rule. The pillow is available in two firmness settings, ‘Medium’ and ‘Firm’; this range should provide sufficient support to most sleepers, including those with larger heads and/or wider shoulders who normally don’t feel comfortable on softer pillows.

The Down Perfect pillow is constructed with three internal chambers. This design ensures the down and feather fill will be evenly distributed with little to no clumping. Both outer chambers contain goose down for softer edges, while the center chamber contains goose feathers to help provide good support and help the pillow maintain a consistent shape. The Down Perfect pillow also sleeps very cool even by feather pillow standards, due in part to the 100% cotton cover.

The Down Perfect pillow is available in Standard, Queen, and King sizes. It is backed by a five-year warranty.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in all weight groups
  • Those who tend to sleep hot
  • Sleepers who do not feel comfortable on softer pillows

JA Comforts Goose Feather Down Pillow – Best Value Feather Pillow

Highlights
  • ‘Soft’
  • 90-night sleep trial and 3-year warranty
  • 95% goose feathers, 5% down
  • Supportive, ergonomic design
  • Great shape retention

Feather pillows can be a cost barrier to many customers due to their relatively high average price-point. Our Best Value pick, the Goose Feather Down Pillow from JA Comforts, is widely sold in packs of two for less than $30, making it much more affordable by comparison. However, the Goose Feather Down Pillow offers the same exceptional softness and temperature neutrality of high-end feather pillow models.

The pillow is also quite supportive; down is used to cushion the edges but feathers constitute most of the fill, giving the pillow more resilience. Shape retention is much better than average. The Goose Feather Down Pillow is can be washed and dried in a conventional machine, as well. Most feather pillows require spot cleaning, making them harder to care for and keep clean.

The Goose Feather Down Pillow is available in a Standard/Queen size. JA Comforts backs the pillow with a 90-night sleep trial and a three-year warranty.

Good for:

  • Side and back sleepers
  • Sleepers in the light and average weight groups
  • Those who tend to sleep hot
  • Sleepers who prefer exceptionally soft pillows

Malouf Z TripleLayer Down Pillow – Best Luxury Feather Pillow

Highlights
  • ‘Soft’
  • 3-year warranty
  • 90% down and 90% feather layers
  • Layered down and feather construction
  • Cool and breathable

The TripleLayer Down Pillow from Malouf’s Z collection is one of the softest feather pillows sold today. The pillow is designed with top and bottom down layers for optimal cushioning, as well as a middle layer of feathers that stabilizes the pillow and provides sleeper support. It also sleeps very cool due to good airflow within the interior, as well as the breathable cover made from unbleached cotton.

The pillow’s soft surface and medium-loft design makes it suitable for all sleep positions. The down padding also prevents feather quills from poking through (a common complaint from feather pillow owners).

The TripleLayer Down Pillow has an above-average price-point, making it a good pick for shoppers with bigger budgets. However, Malouf will make a donation to support survivors of sex trafficking with every purchase of this pillow. The company also offers free shipping anywhere in the contiguous U.S. The TripleLayer Down Pillow is backed by a three-year warranty.

Good for:

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination)
  • Sleepers in the light and average weight groups
  • Those who tend to sleep hot
  • Sleepers who prefer exceptionally soft pillows

Check Price | Read Our Full Malouf Z TripleLayer Down Pillow Review

Three Geese White Feather Pillow – Best Feather Pillow for Side Sleepers

Highlights
  • ‘Medium Firm’
  • 30-night sleep trial
  • Feather and down fill
  • Supportive, multi-chambered construction
  • Aligns the spine and alleviates pressure

Many side sleepers find that feather pillows are too soft and/or not thick enough; this position requires above-average pillow support in order to align the sleeper’s spine and reduce pressure in their most sensitive areas. The White Goose Feather Bed Pillow from Three Geese is more than 4″ thick (making it medium- to high-loft) and considered ‘Medium Firm.’ As a result, side sleepers sink less and experience fewer aches and pains.

This pillow also sleeps very cool, thanks to great air circulation and a cover made from breathable, 600TC Egyptian cotton. The White Goose Feather Bed Pillow is designed with three chambers – down fill in both outer chambers and feathers in the center – to create a cushioning feel that is also resilient.

The White Goose Feather Bed Pillow is available in Queen and King sizes, and widely sold in discounted two-pillow bundles. Three Geese offers a 30-night sleep trial with full refunds for customers who are not satisfied.

Good for:

  • Side and back sleepers
  • Sleepers in the average and heavy weight groups
  • Those who tend to sleep hot
  • Value seekers

Best Feather Pillows Buyer's Guide

Feather pillows are filled with the plumage of ducks, geese, and other waterfowl. The fill primarily consists of exterior feathers, which are fairly coarse; small amounts of underside plumage known as ‘down’ may also be used to provide extra softness. Feather pillows are noted for their durability, and often perform longer than other pillows types. These pillows also retain minimal body heat, allowing them to sleep fairly cool, and they are usually moldable enough for sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow during the night. Their price-point is relatively low compared to other pillow types, as well.

However, there are some drawbacks to using feather pillows. They tend to lose shape when bearing weight, which can create an uneven surface that leaves sleepers susceptible to pain and pressure in the head, neck and shoulders. There is also high odor potential, and the feather fill may produce loud noises when compressed. Feather pillows are also somewhat hard to find, and options for loft and firmness are fairly limited.

Read on to learn more about feather pillows and how they compare to other pillow options.

|What is the Makeup of a Feather Pillow?|

By definition, a feather pillow contains at least 30% exterior feathers and no more than 70% down fill. If a pillow contains 70% or more down, it is typically sold as a ‘down pillow.’ Some pillow manufacturers do not disclose the ratio of down-to-feather fill, but it can be assumed that any model sold as a ‘feather pillow’ has less than 70% down. In fact, the majority of ‘feather pillows’ have roughly 90% to 95% feathers and only 5% to 10% down fill. In most feather pillows, the exterior feathers make up the interior while the down is placed along the edges for a softer feel. Most feather pillow covers have a relatively high thread count in order to prevent the feathers from escaping.

|Which Sizes Are Available for Feather Pillows?|

Feather pillows are commonly available in the following sizes:

  • Standard: This is the most popular pillow size in terms of overall sales. Apart from some Euro sizes, Standards tend to be the shortest and most compact size available. They also tend to have the lowest price-points.
  • Super Standard: Super Standard pillows are two inches longer than Standard pillows. They are made for people who find Standard sizes too compact, but who also don’t toss and turn too much.
  • Queen: Queen-size pillows are four inches longer than Standard pillows. This makes them suitable for people who toss and turn or shift positions throughout the night, as well as those who find Standards to be too compact.  
  • King: The King is generally the longest size (other than body pillows), measuring six inches longer than a Queen and 10 inches longer than a Standard. King-size pillows are ideal for people who toss and turn, and also serve as headrests or backrests for people that sit up in bed to read or watch television.
  • Euro: The Euro size is unique in that the pillow is square-shaped; Euros come in a wide range of different dimensions.
  • Body: Body pillows are exceptionally wide, and are designed for people who like to snuggle with a pillow while they sleep.

The table below features rough measurements for the pillow sizes discussed above.

Pillow SizeDimensions
Standard20W” x 26L”
Super Standard20W” x 28L”
Queen20W” x 30L”
King20W” x 36L”
Euro26W” x 26L”
24W” x 24L”
22W” x 22L”
20W” x 20L”
18W” x 18L”
16W” x 16L”
Body Pillow54W” x 20L”
48W” x 20L”

|Pros and Cons of Feather Pillows|

Pros of feather pillows include:

  • Lifespan: Feather pillows are highly durable, and often perform for at least two to three years.
  • Moldability: Feather pillows are highly moldable, allowing sleepers to scrunch and re-form them in order to achieve their optimal loft.
  • Softness: Because they are so scrunchy, feather pillows are ideal for people who prefer to snuggle with a pillow while they sleep.
  • Weight: Most feather pillows weigh three pounds or less, making them easy to move and adjust for most sleepers.
  • Sleeping Cool: Feather pillows do not retain as much heat as down pillows, allowing sleepers to remain cool and comfortable throughout the night.
  • Price: The average feather pillow costs between $25 and $50, making them fairly affordable compared to other pillow types (including down).

Cons of feather pillows include:

  • Shape: Feather pillows tend to become flattened and misshapen when compressed. As a result, regular shaking and fluffing may be required to maintain a full profile.
  • Support: Because they flatten easily, feather pillows do not provide adequate support for some sleepers. This can cause spinal misalignment, which often leads to added pain and pressure.
  • Odor: Feather pillows typically emit more unpleasant smells than other pillow types.
  • Noise: Many owners say their feather pillow makes crunching and rustling sounds when compressed.
  • Cleaning: Most feather pillows require dry cleaning, which can be expensive over time.
  • Availability: Feather pillow availability is somewhat limited, and some shoppers may not be able to find models that meet their loft and firmness preferences.

|Who Is a Feather Pillow Good for?|

Generally speaking, feather pillows are best suited for the following people:

  • People who sleep on their back or side, although low-loft pillows may be problematic for those who weigh more than 130 pounds.
  • People who tend to sleep hot, since feather beds retain little body heat and usually sleep cool.
  • People who prefer to cuddle with a pillow while they sleep, due to the above-average moldability of feather pillows.

However, feather pillows may not be suitable for the following people:

  • People who sleep on their stomach. These sleepers may sink too deeply into low-loft pillows, whereas high-loft pillows may cause spinal misalignment.
  • People who awaken easily due to noise, as feather pillows can be somewhat loud.
  • People who are sensitive to smell. A large number of feather pillow owners report persistent unpleasant smells.

|Feather Pillow Ratings|

CriteriaFeather Pillow RatingExplanation
AffordabilityFair to GoodWith an average cost of $25 to $50, feather pillows are considered middle-of-the-road in terms of pillow price-point. They are notably cheaper than down pillows.
DurabilityGood to Very GoodAlthough they tend to flatten, most feather pillows will perform for at least two to three years.
SupportPoor to FairFeather pillows are prone to flattening. This may create an uneven surface for the neck and shoulders that leaves these areas vulnerable to pain and pressure.
NoisePoor to FairFeather pillows are among the loudest pillow types due to persistent crunching and rustling sounds.
WeightGood to Very GoodAs the name suggests, feather pillows are fairly lightweight — three pounds or less in most cases.
OdorPoor to FairFeather pillows can be quite smelly, and some owners claim the odors do not dissipate with time.
WashablePoor to FairMost feather pillows must be dry cleaned, making them costlier to maintain than machine washable models.
Firmness/Loft OptionsFair to GoodMost feather pillows are either low- or high-loft, and firmness options may also be somewhat limited.
AvailabilityPoor to FairFeather pillows are somewhat hard to find, particularly with certain loft and firmness settings.

|Buying Tips for Feather Pillows|

Feather pillows are sold through various brick-and-mortar and online home goods retailers, including Bed Bath & Beyond, Walmart, and Macy’s, as well as exclusively online retailers like Amazon.com and Overstock.com. Selections at these locations are somewhat limited compared to other pillow types.

The average feather pillow costs between $25 and $50. By comparison, the average down pillow costs between $70 and $100, while the average down alternative pillow costs between $20 and $30. Feather pillows with higher down concentrations tend to be more expensive than pillows made with 100% feathers, but this is not always the case (see table below).

Most feather pillows require dry cleaning, although some models are machine washable.

The graph below looks at average prices for feather pillows and seven other popular pillow types.

Feather Pillow Price Comparison