Best Cribs – 2019 Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

Our Review Process

 

Tuck’s mattress and sleep product recommendations are based on more than 300,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the product you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

Buying decisions are hard enough, but when it comes to where your baby will lay his or her little head each night, the process can be downright stressful.

There’s a great deal to consider when purchasing a crib. On the top of the list is safety, though it’s important to note that all new cribs must meet current safety standards. Beyond that, you’ll want to know if the crib is made from quality materials that will last. Is the crib easy to assemble, and will it convert to a toddler bed to add to its longevity? Depending on your needs, you’ll also want to balance affordability with special technologies and features. And of course, you want to find a crib that matches your nursery decor.

Read on to learn more about important considerations when buying a crib as well as our top picks for 2019. Our recommendations are based on customer reviews and thorough product research, so let us do the heavy lifting—you have enough to worry about.

Best Cribs of 2019

Editor’s Pick – Davinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible

Best Luxury Crib – Babyletto Hudson Crib

Best Affordable Crib – Storkcraft Pacific Convertible Crib

Best Convertible Crib – Carter’s Colby Convertible Crib

How We Decided

 

19 cribs considered –– 45 hours of research –– 4 sleep experts consulted

The Best Cribs of 2019 - Tuck's Top 4 Picks

Davinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible – Editor's Pick

Highlights
  • Four mattress positions
  • Converts to toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed
  • Quality materials and sturdy construction
  • GREENGUARD Gold-certified
  • Classic design and seven color options

The Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib combines quality construction and functionality, while still being relatively affordable. With four mattress positions and four bed options, the Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib by DaVinci will truly grow with your child. By using conversion kits (sold separately), the crib can become a toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed. The Kalani is also more solidly built than many cribs in this price range, with thicker rails and legs. That means that not only will the crib grow with your child, you can also be confident that it will stay in good shape for years.

The Kalani has a classic design that will fit well in most nurseries and comes in seven colors: chestnut, ebony, espresso, gray, oak, white and cherry. It’s also GREENGUARD Gold-Certified and made from sustainably-sourced New Zealand pine. While it may take longer than some other cribs to assemble, quality craftsmanship means you know this crib is built to last.

Babyletto Hudson Crib – Best Luxury Crib

Highlights
  • Four mattress positions
  • Easy to assemble
  • Converts to toddler and daybed
  • GREENGUARD Gold-certified
  • Sleek, modern design

The Hudson Crib by Babyletto is a high-quality crib with four adjustable mattress positions, so it will grow with your baby. On top of that, it comes with a conversion kit to easily transition it into a toddler bed with side rail or a daybed, both of which can be used until your child is 50 pounds. At just under 35” high, the crib is a bit shorter than similar cribs, so it’s easier to place your baby in the lowest mattress position.

The Hudson has a sleek, mid-century design for the style-conscious parent and comes in a variety of colors, including gray, white, espresso and natural. You can sleep easy knowing the crib is GREENGUARD Gold-certified, meaning it’s been screened for 360 VOCs and over 10,000 chemicals. The crib is great for eco-conscious parents, too, as it’s made from sustainably-sourced New Zealand pine and has non-toxic finishes.

Storkcraft Pacific Convertible Crib – Best Affordable Crib

Highlights
  • More affordable than similar cribs
  • Three mattress positions
  • Can convert to toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed
  • Easy to assemble
  • Simple, clean lines

The Storkcraft Pacific Convertible Crib is one of the more affordable cribs you can find that still has solid construction. Adding to its value is the fact that it can convert to a toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed. Conversion kits for each are sold separately. The crib can be used until your baby is 35” and the toddler/daybed until he or she weighs 50 pounds.

This is a no frills crib that still has a sleek, modern design. Its composed of composite in addition to pine, which helps keep the cost down. The crib is available in black, white, gray and espresso. It’s also low-profile, so you can easily reach down to pick up your baby from the lowest mattress positions. And because the design is simple, it’s also relatively easy to put together.

Carter's Colby Convertible Crib – Best Convertible Crib

Highlights
  • Four mattress positions
  • Can convert to toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed
  • Trundle drawer for extra storage
  • GREENGUARD Gold-Certified
  • Low-profile, clean design

Carter’s Colby Crib by DaVinci is highly versatile, with four mattress positions and the ability to convert to four different bed types. It grows from a crib to a toddler bed to a daybed and finally to a full-size bed. The crib is priced lower than similar models, and though the conversion kits are sold separately, it’s still an excellent value when you consider you’re getting four beds in one. The crib can be used until your baby is 35” high or starts to climb out, and your child will fit in the toddler bed until he or she is 50 pounds. The full-size bed is rated for 500 pounds.

This crib has clean lines and great functionality, including a trundle drawer for extra storage. Three color options are available: gray, white and gray with white slats. The crib is GREENGUARD Gold-certified and made from non-toxic materials, including sustainably-sourced New Zealand pine.

Best Cribs Buying Guide

Purchasing a crib can be a daunting process, but by paying attention to these top considerations, you’re sure to find the crib that’s right for you—and your baby.

Safety

While hand-me-downs and thrift stores are great sources for most baby gear, it’s a good idea to buy new when it comes to cribs. That’s because crib safety standards change over time and all new cribs must adhere to current standards. The latest federal requirements for crib safety were passed in 2011 by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). They prohibit drop-side rails, require stronger slats and mattress supports, require higher quality hardware and outline rigorous testing

In addition to these federal standards, it’s important to check cribs to make sure they feel solid, both before you purchase one and after you assemble it at home. Opt for basic cribs with simple lines rather than decorative cut-outs or finials that can catch on baby’s clothing. Also make sure slats are no more than 2 ? inches apart. And finally, ensure your baby’s sleeping environment is safe by keeping blankets, pillows and soft toys out of the crib, at least before he or she turns one.

Quality of Materials

All new cribs must meet federal guidelines for safety, but that doesn’t mean they were all created equal when it comes to material quality and durability. Especially if you’re purchasing a convertible crib that you plan to hang onto for a few years, you’ll want to choose one made with materials that will last. Hardwoods, like beech and poplar, tend to hold up better against dings and nicks than softer woods, like pine. Hardwood cribs also tend to cost more, however. Some cribs also feature solid panels at the head and foot made from fiberboard, which tends to be somewhat flimsy.

Affordability

Crib prices can vary widely, from just over a hundred dollars all the way up to a couple thousand. Choose the crib that best fits your budget, keeping in mind that higher priced cribs may have better quality materials—to a point. Very expensive cribs tend to have details that you might find unnecessary, like hand-crafted elements or appliqued molding. It’s fairly easy to find a quality crib for a few hundred dollars.

In addition to material quality, you’ll want to consider looking for a convertible crib to get the best value. Being able to convert your crib into a toddler bed or even full-size bed is a great way to stretch your dollar.

Ease of Assembly

Sitting in a nursery surrounded by crib parts may seem like a parenthood right of passage, but it doesn’t have to be that difficult. Some cribs are simply easier to assemble than others. Check out assembly instructions online before purchasing a crib, and pay extra attention to the number of parts and tools required. Some cribs come completely disassembled into several parts, while others just require you attach the four sides and mattress support.

In theory, you only need to assemble your crib once (or once for each child), but you will have to move the mattress position as your baby grows. Check the process for that to make sure it’s simple. Proper assembly is also vital in ensuring crib safety, so a crib that’s easier to put together might be the best choice.

Design

Some parents spend months designing their dream nurseries while others throw everything together at the last minute. Either way, the crib plays a central role. There are cribs for every taste, from sleek and modern to traditional to unique. Some cribs come in a variety of colors or wood tones. Especially if you want to keep your crib for several years through multiple children, you may want to pick a classic or simple design so it fits with a variety of nurseries.

Design can impact more than aesthetics. It can also play into durability, as very thin slats or legs tend to be less sturdy over time. Low-profile cribs that sit lower to the ground can also be more functional for shorter parents as it’s easier to reach in to pick up baby.

When Do I Need a Crib?

A crib is the quintessential piece of baby furniture, but there’s variation in how different families use them and when. Will your baby sleep in his crib from day one or move into it after a few months? How old will your child be when he transitions out of his crib, and how do you know when that time has come?

The truth is that baby sleep is more of an art than a science, and the answers to these questions depend on several variables, including safety considerations, how your house is set up, your baby and your own sleep needs. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that infants sleep in their parents’ rooms for at least their first six months, and ideally a year.  If you have a small bedroom, fitting a full-sized crib in it might not be an option, so you may opt for a smaller bassinet while you room-share. Once your child is ready to move into her own room, she’ll transition to a crib. If you can fit a crib in your room or like the idea of only purchasing one bed for your baby, then your little one may sleep in a crib from day one.

The age at which babies transition to sleeping in a crib in their own rooms also varies. While the AAP recommendation is six months, a recent study shows that room-sharing can lead to interrupted sleep. Parents and babies who are light sleepers may wake each other up all night. This can cause parents to opt for less safe sleep practices, like bed-sharing. As a family, you have to weigh the options and choose to move your child into his own crib in his own room when it feels right to you.

A crib is an important purchase because your child will spend a great deal of time in it. In fact, by the time they’re two years old, children will have spent 40 percent of their lives asleep. While every child is different, expect your child to sleep in her crib for around two years. Some children start climbing out of their cribs earlier, at which point it’s safer to transition to a toddler bed. Others stay in their cribs for longer, which is perfectly fine as long as they don’t exceed weight limits for their cribs.

Safe Sleep and Cribs

Safety is a top concern when choosing a new crib, and it’s equally important to consider safe sleeping once you have your crib. Here are some practices to keep in mind:

  • Place baby on back to sleep: The safest position for a baby to sleep is on her back. This position lowers the risk of SIDS and helps prevent airways being blocked from being face down.
  • Keep sleep surface bare: The safest crib is an empty crib. Until your baby is one, keep his crib free from everything but a fitted sheet. Use a wearable blanket instead of loose ones.
  • Ensure firm sleep surface: A firm crib mattress is the safest option because it lowers the risk of suffocation or rolling. Some mattresses have a firm infant side and a slightly plusher toddler side.
  • Choose safe mattress height: Current cribs have at least two mattress heights, so be sure to lower your mattress once your baby is able to sit on his own and again when he can stand.

Additional Tuck Resources

Want to learn more about pediatric sleep and our top picks for other baby sleep products? Take a look at some of our other articles below.