Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages
guides
products
Filter by Categories
Baby Sleep Products
Bedding
Bedding FAQs
Circadian
Circadian rhythm sleep-wake disorders
Diagnosis
How Sleep Works
Hypersomnias
Insomnias
Mattress 101
Mattress Accessories
Mattress Brands
Mattress Comparisons
Mattress FAQs
Mattresses
Non-Drug Therapies
PAP Therapies
Parasomnias
Pet Sleep Resources
Popular
Safety and Sleep
Sales and Coupons
Sleep Disorders
Sleep Environment
Sleep Products
Sleep Resources
Sleep-related breathing disorders
Sleep-related movement disorders
Uncategorized
Tuck's editors test & choose the products we write about. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

Brooklinen vs. Boll & Branch – Our 2020 Sheet Comparison

Written by - Lauren Fountain.

The Bottom Line.

  • Brooklinen and Boll & Branch both offer high-quality sheets and sheet sets made from cotton and linen.
  • Boll & Branch offers a 100% organic cotton option.
  • Brooklinen’s cooling sheets provide exceptional temperature regulation.

Compare Offers

Brooklinen-Classic-Core-Sheets

Tuck readers get 10% off at Brooklinen with code: TUCK10

Boll & Branch Solid Hemmed Sheet Set

Interested in a sheet set from Boll & Branch?

Meet Our Testing Team
Keith
Keith
Jeremy
Jeremy
Jackson
Jackson
Brad
Brad

Brooklinen vs. Boll & Branch Overview

Brooklinen got its start in 2014, when Brooklyn couple Rich and Vicki Fulop launched a Kickstarter campaign to fund their dream company. Driven by the desire to make comfortable, affordable sheets made from all-natural materials, Brooklinen’s founders keep costs low by cutting out the middleman and selling their products exclusively online. Brooklinen’s 270-thread count Classic Core sheet set is made from 100 percent long-staple cotton.

Founded by Scott and Missy Tannen in 2013, Boll & Branch strives to provide ethically produced, environmentally sound textile products at an affordable price. Boll & Branch exclusively uses 100 percent organic cotton, prioritizing workers’ rights and sustainable practices. All textiles are made with raw, non-GMO materials and shipped in 100 percent recycled packaging. Boll & Branch’s flagship Percale sheet set offers a crisp, tailored sleep experience in multiple colors and patterns.

  • Please note: Both Brooklinen and Boll & Branch sell models additional to the items listed above.

Brooklinen also offers a Luxe Collection, which features sheets and sheet sets made from 100 percent long-staple cotton in a sateen weave, as well as a linen collection made from 100 percent flax linen.

Boll & Branch also sells a 100 percent linen collection, as well as a flannel collection made from organic cotton.

Brooklinen and Boll & Branch offer lightweight, durable sheets that are consistently highly rated for their exceptional comfort. Deeply committed to sustainability and ethical consumption, both companies use top-quality materials to make environmentally friendly products. However, each brand features its own unique qualities and benefits. Let’s look at how our testing team rated both types of sheets on cost, comfort, durability, and other vital fields, along with each company’s shipping, warranties, and return policies.

Ratings Comparison

Classic Core Sheets

Percale Solid Sheets

Materials 100% Long-Staple Cotton100% organic cotton
Weave PercalePercale
Sizes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California KingTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Tap here to see more mattress stats
  • Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
  • Boll & Branch Percale Solid Sheets

Full Sleep Rating

Criteria
Rating
Durability
Temperature Regulation
Comfort & Feel
Cleaning
Fit

Full Sleep Rating

Criteria
Rating
Durability
Temperature Regulation
Comfort & Feel
Cleaning
Fit
  • Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
  • Boll & Branch Percale Solid Sheets
Durability
Temperature Regulation
Comfort & Feel
Cleaning
Fit
Durability
Temperature Regulation
Comfort & Feel
Cleaning
Fit
#

Durability

The majority of customers seem happy with the durability of the sheets, though some note they are more lightweight than expected.

#

Durability

The majority of customers seem happy with the durability of the sheets, though some note they are more lightweight than expected.

#

Temperature Regulation

Most customers are happy with how the sheets regulate temperature, find them to sleep cool.

#

Temperature Regulation

Most customers are happy with how the sheets regulate temperature, find them to sleep cool.

#

Comfort & Feel

Users for the most part find the sheets to be very cozy and comfortable in feel.

#

Comfort & Feel

Users for the most part find the sheets to be very cozy and comfortable in feel.

#

Cleaning

These sheets are machine-washable, but some customers report pilling after repeated washing.

#

Cleaning

These sheets are machine-washable, but some customers report pilling after repeated washing.

#

Fit

A few customers reported issues with the fitted sheet bunching up in the middle or the flat sheet not being long enough to tuck under the bed, but most seemed pleased with the fit.

#

Fit

A few customers reported issues with the fitted sheet bunching up in the middle or the flat sheet not being long enough to tuck under the bed, but most seemed pleased with the fit.

#

Durability

The long-staple cotton, high thread count, and tight percale weave all contribute to excellent durability for these sheets. They are built to last, and it shows in the final product.

#

Durability

The long-staple cotton, high thread count, and tight percale weave all contribute to excellent durability for these sheets. They are built to last, and it shows in the final product.

#

Temperature Regulation

As a fabric, cotton excels at facilitating comfort cooling. It does this by pulling moisture away from the body, allowing it to evaporate and maintain a well-regulated temperature. The percale weave offers the maximum in breathability and gives a noticeably cool and crisp feel when up against your skin.

#

Temperature Regulation

As a fabric, cotton excels at facilitating comfort cooling. It does this by pulling moisture away from the body, allowing it to evaporate and maintain a well-regulated temperature. The percale weave offers the maximum in breathability and gives a noticeably cool and crisp feel when up against your skin.

#

Comfort & Feel

Customers report high levels of satisfaction with the feel of these sheets and their crisp yet soft and inviting feel.

#

Comfort & Feel

Customers report high levels of satisfaction with the feel of these sheets and their crisp yet soft and inviting feel.

#

Cleaning

A quick trip through the washer and dryer is all that’s needed to keep these sheets clean and fresh. However, a quick pass of the iron may be necessary to eliminate wrinkles.

#

Cleaning

A quick trip through the washer and dryer is all that’s needed to keep these sheets clean and fresh. However, a quick pass of the iron may be necessary to eliminate wrinkles.

#

Fit

Customers rarely report fit issues with these sheets. They stay tight to the mattress and fit mattresses up to 17” deep.

#

Fit

Customers rarely report fit issues with these sheets. They stay tight to the mattress and fit mattresses up to 17” deep.

Ratings Summary

Are you looking for cooling sheets with exceptional breathability? During our in-house testing, our team praised Brooklinen sheets for their comfort, moisture wicking weave, and temperature regulating properties. Testers also found that Brooklinen products fit true to size. Most Brooklinen sheets are available in sets or as individual pieces, allowing customers to mix and match colors and styles.

In contrast, Boll & Branch sheets are only available in sets. Like Brooklinen products, however, these sheets are made from durable, all-natural cotton. Our testers consistently gave the Boll & Branch sheets high ratings for their comfort and feel, and praised the company’s Percale sheets for their ease of care. Boll & Branch sheets are also notable for using 100% organic and Fair Trade Certified materials.

Our Recommendations

Choose the Brooklinen Sheets if...

  • You are looking for an affordable sheet starter set
  • You want to mix and match colors and patterns
  • You want sheets that will help keep you cool
  • You prefer sheets made from all-natural materials

Choose the Boll & Branch Sheets if...

  • You prefer sheets made from 100% organic and Fair Trade Certified materials
  • You prioritize durability and comfort
  • You want a complete sheet set
  • You are seeking a variety of patterns

Technical Details Comparison

Sizing and Pricing

  • twin-bed
    Twin/Twin XL $109 Brooklinen $210 Boll & Branch
  • twin-bed
    Full $129 Brooklinen $220 Boll & Branch
  • twin-bed
    Queen $129 Brooklinen $240 Boll & Branch
  • twin-bed
    King/Cal King $149 Brooklinen $250-260 Boll & Branch

Materials & Construction

Now, let’s compare how Brooklinen and Boll & Branch sheets are made. The following table describes each brand’s material, weave, and bundle options, along with available patterns and colors.

Specification Brooklinen Boll & Branch
Material 100% Long-Staple Cotton 100% Organic Cotton
Weave Percale Weave Percale Weave
Bundle Options Full sets and individual pieces available for purchase Sets available for purchase

Starter Sleep Bundle (5 pc.)

Complete Sleep Bundle (9 pc.)

Colors/Patterns Available Comes in 12+ colors and patterns 5 colors available

How Are Brooklinen Sheets Made?

Made from 100% long-staple cotton, Brooklinen’s Classic Core sheets feature a 270-thread count percale weave. The all-natural breathable material is durable and cooling, making it ideal for customers who tend to sleep hot. While the company’s popular Luxe Sateen line is also made from long-staple cotton, these sheets feature a luxurious 480-thread count and sateen weave that gives them an elegant sheen. Both collections are available in more than 15 colors and patterns.

Brooklinen’s lightweight washed linen line is made from Belgian and French flax and dyed in small batches, giving each piece a unique flair. These ultra-soft sheets are made in Portugal and come in 10 different colors. Like the Classic Collection and the Luxe Sateen line, Brooklinen’s washed linen products are OEKO-TEX certified against harmful substances and meet strict global safety standards.

How Are Boll & Branch Sheets Made?

Boll & Branch’s Signature Soft and Percale lines are both made from 100 percent organic long-staple Fair Trade Certified cotton. However, the best-selling Signature line features a sateen weave, which leaves the sheets feeling extra soft and giving them a sheen. Customers can choose their Signature sheets in more than 12 colors and two styles. The Percale collection offers a smooth, crisp sleeping experience available in two styles and six stripes. Both lines are available in sets.

In addition, Boll & Branch offers a 100 percent woven linen option in a shore stripe pattern and a flannel set. Available in five colors and patterns, the flannel line is also made from 100 percent organic cotton.

Cleaning and Care for Brooklinen Sheets

With the right kind of care, Brooklinen sheets will get softer with every wash. The company suggests that customers machine wash sheets on a warm or cool setting. While customers are encouraged to line dry their sheets for best results, those who prefer to machine dry should do so on a low heat, low tumble setting.

Brooklinen also partners with a detergent brand called Laundress. Plant-based, gentle, and biodegradable, the line provides Brooklinen products with optimal care. Customers can purchase Laundress detergent, bleach alternative, fabric refresher spray, and wool and cashmere shampoo. A product bundle containing detergent, fabric conditioner, fabric spray, and bleach alternative is also available.

Cleaning and Care for Boll & Branch Sheets

Boll & Branch sheets are easy to clean and feature simple care instructions, although laundering directions differ for cotton and linen items. Their white or light-colored Percale, Signature Soft, and Flannel sheets should be machine washed in warm water, while cold water is ideal for all other colors. These sheets can be dried on a medium setting and ironed as needed. Cotton items may develop a slight sheen after ironing.

The company’s 100 percent woven linen sheets may also be ironed after washing and drying. Linen should be laundered in cold water with similar colors and tumble-dried on low heat. Customers should remove their linen sheets from the dryer immediately after the cycle has completed.

Brooklinen Sleep Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

  • Sleep Trial 1 Year

  • Shipping Ships to many countries around the world

  • Warranty Lifetime, limited

  • Made In Israel (Classic and Luxe); Portugal (Linen)

  • How are the Sheets Shipped?

    Items ship in 1-2 business days; orders placed before 2 p.m. Monday through Friday are shipped that same day.

  • Where Do They Ship?

    Brooklinen ships to nearly every country in the world.

  • Full Shipping Details

    Free shipping and returns/exchanges are available within the United States. Brooklinen currently ships to Hong Kong, Canada, Australia, Singapore, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Israel, Japan, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, South Korea, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom, and U.S. Minor Outlying Islands. Free return shipping is not available for international returns or exchanges. Orders placed before 1 p.m. Monday through Friday ship the same business day. Those placed after 1 p.m. during the week ship on the following day. Orders placed after 1 p.m. on Fridays or during weekends will ship on the following Monday.

  • Trial Period Details

    Brooklinen offers a 365-night sleep trial for the Classic Core Sheet Set.

    Brooklinen offers customers a generous 365-night trial period to ensure they are fully satisfied with their sheets. During this one-year period, customers may return their purchases and receive a refund using their original payment method or store credit. Purchasers may also exchange their items for another Brooklinen product. The company offers free return and exchange shipping within the United States. International customers who wish to return or exchange their purchases should contact Brooklinen’s customer service department to learn more about shipping conditions and costs.

     

  • Warranty

    Brooklinen offers a lifetime limited warranty.

    Brooklinen is proud to sell high-quality products made from exceptionally durable materials and offers a lifetime limited warranty on all of its textiles. If your Brooklinen sheets rip, fray, or tear, or you are otherwise dissatisfied with your purchase, you are encouraged to contact Brooklinen’s customer service department and discuss your return and exchange options.

Brooklinen Coupons and Discounts

Tuck readers save 10% at Brooklinen.

Use code: TUCK10

CHECK PRICE

Boll & Branch Sleep Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

  • Sleep Trial 30 nights

  • Shipping U.S. and Canada

  • Warranty Limited, 1-year

  • Made In USA

  • How are the Sheets Shipped?

    All Boll & Branch items are shipped Monday through Friday.

  • Where Do They Ship?

    Boll & Branch ships to the U.S. and Canada.

  • Full Shipping Details

    All Boll & Branch customers within the U.S. receive free ground shipping. U.S. customers may also select 1- or 2-day shipping at an additional cost. Brooklinen ships all items Monday through Friday and does not offer weekend deliveries. Most standard-shipping orders arrive within 2-10 business days of placing the order, although exact dates vary by location. While return shipping is free, all returns must be processed within 30 days of purchase. Shipping costs, taxes, and duties for customers in Canada vary according to province. International purchases may not be returned.

  • Trial Period Details

    Boll & Branch offers a 30-night sleep trial for the Percale Sheet Set.

    Boll & Branch’s trial period allows customers who are not satisfied with their purchase can return the item or items within 30 days. Refunds are issued in the original payment form and processed within 5-10 days. Boll & Branch offers free return shipping via UPS. Individuals who wish to exchange their purchase for a different item should contact customer service to initiate the return process before using their refund to purchase the desired product.

    All returns and exchanges must be completed within 30 days. Boll & Branch does not accept international returns or offer refunds or exchanges for gift cards. Purchases made with gift cards will be refunded back to a gift card.

  • Warranty

    Boll & Branch offers a 1-year limited warranty. 

    All Boll & Branch sheets are covered by a 1-year limited warranty, and the company will replace all defective items. While the warranty expires after one year, customers with questions or concerns regarding Boll & Branch products are encouraged to contact the customer service department to resolve any issues.

Boll & Branch Coupons and Discounts

Considering Boll & Branch Sheets?

Tuck readers get the best price.

Get Discount
Table of Contents