Best Pillows for Stomach Sleepers – Our Picks and Buyer’s Guide

Our Review Process

 

Tuck’s mattress and bedding recommendations are based on more than 300,000 verified customer experiences and our team’s exhaustive testing procedure. We never recommend a product we haven’t personally experienced and tested in our lab. You can rest assured, when you’re ready to buy, the sleep product you pick meets Tuck’s lofty standards.

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Read more about how we’re supported here.
Quick Summary

Stomach sleeping is the least common sleep position. According to many medical experts, it is also the unhealthiest option because it leaves sleepers vulnerable to high levels of pain and pressure in their neck and shoulders. However, many adults prefer sleeping on their stomachs over other positions. These sleepers must carefully select their bedding materials in order to ensure sleep quality and duration.

Choosing a pillow can be tricky for stomach sleepers because most models are primarily designed for side and/or back sleepers. Pillow loft, or thickness, is an important consideration; excessively thin or excessively thick pillows will affect how well the neck aligns with the spine. The pillow’s fill and cover material are other variables to take into account, as sleeping face-down often requires softer, more breathable surfaces.

This guide will explore the unique pillow considerations for stomach sleepers. Below you will find our top five picks for stomach sleeping pillows sold today. Our choices are based on verified customer and owner experiences, as well as intensive product research and analysis.

Best Pillows for Stomach Sleepers

Editor’s Pick – Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow

Best Price – PlushBeds Down Blend Pillow

Best Luxury – The Saatva Pillow

Best Down Pillow – Parachute Down Pillow (Soft)

Best Foam – Tuft & Needle Pillow

How We Decided

 

70 pillows considered –– 100 hours of research –– 4 sleep experts consulted

The Best Pillows for Stomach Sleepers – Tuck's Top 5 Pillows

Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow – Editor's Pick

True Brooklyn

Highlights
  • CertiPUR-US Certified
  • Made using natural, sustainable ingredients
  • Moisture-wicking cover lets you sleep cool
  • Antimicrobial and hypoallergenic
  • Machine washable

We chose the Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow as our Editor’s Pick for stomach sleepers because, in terms of quality, cost, and comfort, it has the greatest potential to appeal a large cross section of stomach sleepers. It’s made using high-quality ingredients, such as the sap of the Hevea breasiliensis tree and sustainably sourced Talalay latex.

The pillow has a moisture-wicking, antimicrobial cover; it’s not only highly breathable but it provides a hygienic and dry sleep environment. The airflow through this pillow is several times better than other latex foams, making it perfect for hot sleepers. The Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow is CertiPUR-US® Certified, meaning it’s free of toxins and meets industry health standards.

Brooklyn Bedding’s pillow is hyper-responsive, offering a tremendous amount of head and neck support. At the same time, it promotes proper spinal alignment, no matter what position you find yourself sleeping in.

Good For:

  • Those who want a cooling pillow
  • Anyone with allergies
  • Providing head, neck, and spine support

PlushBeds Down Blend Pillow – Best Price

plush down

Highlights
  • Thick 250-count cotton layer
  • CertiPUR-US, GOLS, and OEKO-TEX certified
  • Cotton layer reduces allergens and dust mites
  • Generous head and neck support comfort

Customers who want the feel of premium comfort without having to spend a lot of money should strongly consider buying the Plushbeds Down Blend Pillow. Plushbeds’ plush, breathable pillow is a down and feather blend surrounded by a thick 250 count cotton layer. The generous cotton layer protects sleepers from feeling sharp quills. Additionally, this cotton layer reduces allergens and dust mites.

Overall, the Plushbeds Down Pillow provides a good amount of loft and offers generous head and neck support to sleepers.

PlushBeds stands by the quality of its products, which have several certifications. Product certifications include CertiPUR-US, Global Organic Latex Standard  (GOLS), and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 Certification.

Good For:

    • Those who suffer from allergies
    • Anyone needing neck and back support
    • Shoppers who want a good pillow without spending too much

The Saatva Pillow – Best Luxury

Highlights
  • Made using natural, renewable materials
  • The inner core is hypoallergenic and mildew-proof
  • Moisture-wicking sateen cover
  • Dust-mite resistant

The Saatva Pillow is for anyone who’s ever stayed at a luxurious hotel and fell in love with their high-quality pillows. The pillow is a combination of 100 percent organic cotton, micro-denier fiber, and shredded 100 percent American Talalay latex . It’s encased in a highly breathable sateen cover that wicks away moisture and was designed to promote maximum airflow, letting you sleep cool and dry. The Saatva Pillow is responsibly constructed, made using all-natural, renewable materials.

The Saatva Pillow’s removable inner core is comprised of highly-responsive latex, providing head and neck support. In addition, this core is naturally hypoallergenic, dust-mite resistant, and mildew-proof. The outer pillow is washable; just use the zipper to remove the pillow’s core before cleaning it.

Good For:

  • Those who want hotel-quality pillows
  • Providing a cooler sleep experience on hot nights
  • Anyone needing good neck and back support
  • Those who want environmentally-friendly products
  • Anyone concerned about pillow-related allergens

The Parachute Down Pillow (Soft) – Best Down Pillow

Parachute Down

Highlights
  • Filled with premium European white down
  • 100 percent sateen cotton shell
  • Double-stitched piping seam for durability
  • Three-year warranty

Parachute’s Down Pillow has just the right amount of loft to keep your neck in a comfortable, neutral position. You don’t have to worry about neck pain and stiffness due to sleeping with your neck in a non-supported position for several hours. Additionally, Parachute’s European white down filling is repurposed in a sustainable and ethical manner. For maximum comfort, stomach sleepers should choose the “soft” option.

The pillow filling is encased  in a 100 percent sateen weave cotton shell and reinforced with a double-stitched piping seam. Parachute’s Down Pillow provides a luxurious, supportive feel for your head, while still feeling airy and light.

It’s best to dry clean the Parachute Down Pillow, but you can machine wash it on cool using a “delicate” cycle setting. Parachute recommends its laundry detergent when machine washing its pillows. Tumble dry low with Wool Dryer Balls. Promptly remove these pillows from the dryer.

Good For:

  • Those who experience neck pain and stiffness
  • Anyone who wants to be sure their purchase is cruelty-free
  • Those who want a breathable, plush and also durable pillow

The Tuft & Needle Pillow – Best Foam

Highlights
  • Each side sleeps cool
  • Supportive and firm foam core
  • Removable, washable pillow cover
  • 100-day risk-free trial

When you settle down to sleep, you don’t want to spend half the evening flipping your pillow over to escape the heat. The Tuft & Needle Pillow sleeps cool as it features the same cooling foam used in its mattresses. This “Adaptive” foam features a heat wicking graphite material and cooling gel. Together, they make any side of the pillow crisply refreshing so that  pillow flipping becomes a thing of the past.

This plush pillow was designed to fit any standard pillowcase. The cotton cover is washable, just allow it to air dry. Do not wash the actual pillow. Free shipping is available only within the 48 contiguous states. Tuft & Needle only ships to US residents.

Good For:

  • Those who want a good cooling pillow
  • Sleepers who don’t want to fluff or adjust their pillow

Best Pillows for Stomach Sleepers Buying Guide

Stomach sleeping (or front sleeping) is a challenging position for most people, and most doctors do not recommend it. Sleeping on the stomach often causes neck strain from craning one’s neck to one side, and spinal strain due to uneven weight distribution.

Pillow selection can make a world of difference for stomach sleepers. Pillows that are overly thick can cause them to turn their head or bend their neck to one side, which may cause aches and pains to develop. However, pillows that are too thin may not provide enough support, which can also lead to discomfort.

This guide will explore pillow options for stomach sleepers. We’ll look at the mechanics of sleeping on one’s stomach, important considerations for pillow shoppers, and our picks for the best pillows for stomach sleepers.

What You Need to Know About Stomach Sleeping

stomach sleep positionStomach sleeping is the least common sleep position. An estimated 6% to 7% of adults regularly sleep on their stomachs. Most utilize the ‘freefall’ position (as illustrated), with both hands resting below the head while one leg is slightly bent at the knee and the other is fully extended.

Advantages

Generally speaking, physicians discourage the stomach sleeping position. However, there are two notable advantages to sleeping on one’s stomach:

  • Lower snoring potential: Like side sleepers, stomach sleepers are less susceptible to heavy snoring than back sleepers. This is because the muscles in breathing passages tend to relax when one sleeps on his or her back. This can cause the airway to restrict, as well as the tongue to block the airway. Both of these issues can increase snoring.
  • Fewer wrinkles: Many side sleepers develop wrinkles in places that rest directly on the pillow. Most stomach sleepers do not develop wrinkles as quickly, although sleeping with one’s face directly on the pillow may cause wrinkles to form.

Disadvantages

Physicians often discourage stomach sleeping because of potential health risks and major comfort issues. A few disadvantages for stomach sleepers include:

  • Spinal strain: Most adults carry a high concentration of weight in their stomachs, and sleeping on your back or side essentially gives them a much-needed break from carrying that weight. Sleeping on one’s stomach has the opposite effect: it can pull the body down and cause the spine curvature to flatten. This often leads to pain and pressure points along the vertebrae.
  • Neck pain potential: Most stomach sleepers turn their head to one side because it is not comfortable to lay face-down on their pillow or mattress. This is a common cause of neck strain among stomach sleepers.
  • Not comfortable for most pregnant women: Stomach sleeping while pregnant is not harmful to fetal health, but most women find this position increasingly uncomfortable as their bellies grow.
  • Sleep disruption risk: Stomach sleeping can be so uncomfortable for some that it causes them to toss and turn all night, searching for an adequate position. This can affect overall sleep quality and leave them feeling tired the next day.

It’s important to note that changing a sleep position can be a difficult task — and the longer someone sleeps in a certain position, the harder it will be to adjust their routine.

While stomach sleeping is not recommended, it may the position that you find most comfortable.

To minimize some of the aches and pains associated with this position, try sleeping with a thin pillow beneath your stomach. This will alleviate some of the pressure associated with uneven weight distribution and help the spine maintain its natural curvature.

Choosing the Right Pillow for Stomach Sleepers

Selecting the best possible pillow is important for stomach sleepers, as comfort is a common issue. You must be mindful of providing the right amount of neck and back support, and you want to make sure your pillow won’t inhibit proper breathing. Below you’ll find a series of common considerations to keep in mind when choosing the right pillow.

Size

You might be surprised, but pillow size is actually one of the most important considerations for selecting a pillow. Too small and the pillow won’t provide the best possible head and neck support, while the right-sized pillow can prevent the urge to toss and turn through the night.

Pillows for stomach sleepers generally come in six standard sizes.

Standard (20W” x 26L”): The most common pillow size, as well as the most compact and — in most cases — the least expensive. Standard pillows may not be ideal for people who toss and turn, as they are often too narrow and may cause the sleeper’s head to slip off the sides.

Super Standard (20W” x 28L”): The Super Standard is considered a wider alternative to the Standard, making it suitable for some people who toss and turn, but others may still find it too narrow. Super Standards are also somewhat uncommon.

Queen (20W” x 30L”): The Queen is four inches wider than a Standard, and will be suitable for most sleepers who toss and turn.

King (20W” x 36L”): The King is a full 10 inches wider than the Standard. This means it will not only accommodate those who toss and turn, but may also serve as a comfy headrest or backrest for people who like to read or watch television in bed.

Euro (dimensions vary): Unlike the other standard sizes, which are rectangular, Euro pillows are square-shaped. They come in a wide range of dimensions; common options include 20W” x 20L” and 26W” x 26L”. Most sleepers in the U.S. do not use them as primary sleeping pillows, but they (like Kings) make good headrests and backrests.

Body (48-54W” x 20L”): Body pillows are the longest size and are fairly popular with sleepers who like to snuggle with a pillow while they sleep. However, most stomach sleepers prefer not to straddle a pillow during the night.

Additionally, a specialty ‘Small’ size is often available for cervical memory foam pillows, which are elevated beneath the neck and recessed below the head. However, these will not be suitable for the vast majority of stomach sleepers, who generally need thin, even-surface pillows.

Loft

Loft is arguably the most important consideration for stomach sleepers. There are three general categories for pillow loft:

Low-loft: Pillows that measure less than three inches (3?) thick.
Medium-loft: Pillows that measure three to five inches (3? to 5?) thick.
High-loft: Pillows that measure more than five inches (5?) thick.

For most stomach sleepers, choosing loft can be a compromise. The majority of high-loft pillows — as well as many medium-loft pillows — will be excessively thick. As we’ve discussed above, this can lead to strain in the neck and spine. However, some low-loft pillows may be too thin to adequately support the sleeper’s head. Generally, stomach sleepers feel most comfortable on low- and medium-loft pillows measuring two to five inches (2? to 5?). However, this is entirely subjective and sleeping position is only one of the factors to consider when choosing the right loft. Other variables include the sleeper’s body weight, head size, and shoulder width, as well as their mattress firmness. The table below uses these criteria to break down each loft category.

Loft Category Thickness Optimal Weight Optimal Head Size Optimal Shoulder Width Optimal Mattress Firmness
Low Less than 3″ More than 230 lbs. Small Narrow Soft to Medium Soft
Medium 3″ to 5″ 130 to 230 lbs. Average Average Medium
High More than 5″ Less than 130 lbs. Large Broad Medium Firm to Firm

Adjustable-loft pillows are a suitable option for stomach sleepers with varying thickness preferences. These pillows allow owners to remove or add fill in order to decrease or increase the loft.

Material

Pillows may be made from a wide assortment of fill materials, and each option has its own benefits and drawbacks. Stomach sleepers tend to prefer pillows that conform to their head and provide sufficient support while not feeling too thick or firm. However, other factors to consider include temperature, cost, and odor/allergy potential. The next table takes a closer look at the construction, pros, cons, and stomach sleeper suitability of the seven most common pillow materials.

Pillow Material Filling Description Pros Cons Stomach Sleeper Rating
Buckwheat Roughly five to 10 lbs. of removable buckwheat hulls (outer shells) Adjustable loft
Close conforming
Good support
Sleeps cool
High price-point
Too firm for some
Noise potential
Heavy
Fair
Buckwheat pillows offer adjustable loft, but they may be excessively firm for stomach sleepers
Down Removable duck or goose down, which are the soft inner plumage found beneath the outer feathers Adjustable loft
Very soft and lightweight
Sleeps cool
Short break-in
Long lifespan
High price-point
Poor shape retention
Fluffing needed
Allergy and odor potential
Very Good
Down pillows can be adjusted for loft, and are often thin — yet supportive — enough for stomach sleepers
Down Alternative Polyester puffballs that mimic the softness and weight or authentic down Adjustable loft
Low price-point
Very soft and lightweight
Short break-in
No allergy risk
Short lifespan
Poor shape retention
Fluffing needed
Short lifespan
Fair
Down alternative pillows tend to lose shape easily, which can cause discomfort
Feather Outer feathers of ducks or geese (may also include some down for extra softness) Adjustable loft
Close conforming
Very soft and lightweight
Long lifespan
High cost
Quills can poke
Fluffing needed
May sleep hot
Odor potential
Good
Feather pillows may be too soft, but stomach sleepers can adjust the loft according to their preferences
Latex Solid latex, which is a natural substance extracted from the sap of rubber trees Close conforming
Good support
Close conforming
Long lifespan
Sleep cool
No noise
Non-adjustable loft
High cost
Too dense and heavy for some
Odor potential
Fair
Latex pillows conform and cradle the head, but most models are too thick (high-loft) for stomach sleepers
Memory Foam Shredded or solid memory foam, or viscoelastic polyfoam, which softens when warm and retains shape when cool Adjustable loft (shredded)
Close conforming
No noise
High cost
Short lifespan
Odor potential
Very Good
Most memory foam pillows are suitable for stomach sleepers because they are supportive and relatively thin
Polyester Shredded or interlocking polyester fibers; polyester is a synthetic fabric Low cost
Good shape retention (interlocking)
No allergy risk
No odor potential
Short lifespan
Poor shape retention (shredded)
Noise potential
Poor
Interlocking polyester pillows are usually too thick for stomach sleepers, while shredded polyester pillows lose shape too easily
Polyfoam A foam created by adding water to polyurethane plastics. Typically inexpensive
Durable
Bouncy
Springy
Highly resilient
Light in weight
Can be low-quality and degrade quickly
Little airflow

Fair to Good High-quality polyfoam pillows can provide firm comfort, but lower quality pillows lack comfort and support

Moldability

Moldability refers to how easily a pillow can be scrunched or reshaped to accommodate different head and neck positions. This is important for stomach sleepers, particularly those who have a hard time getting comfortable and need to move their pillow around during the night.

Cost

Finally, let’s explore cost expectations for different pillow types. The table below lists average price ranges for each of the seven pillow materials described above — but costs often vary by brand and model.

Material Average Price
Buckwheat $50 to $75
Down $70 to $100
Down Alt. $20 to $30
Feather $25 to $50
Latex $40 to $60
Memory Foam $50 to $60
Polyester $10 to $15
Polyfoam $40 to $100

Additional Tuck Resources

To learn more about different pillow materials and pillow options for different sleepers, please visit the following pages on Tuck.com: